Awful
Sorry to voice a dissenting opinion, but I thought this movie was awful. I watched it because I respect the work of Goldwyn, Howard, and Feore -- unfortunately, I was not impressed.
The plotline came across like a Stephen King rip-off. The characters were trite archetypes (A priest, a lawyer, and a cop? Really?). The dialogue, especially in the scenes involving the adult characters, was thin and amateur. The "twists" were dumb and predictable. Almost none of the story was believable. I half suspected this was a script written as a final project for some film class.
There was much that could have been done with the theme of guilt but I finished the film very disappointed.