MovieChat Forums > Myst (1993) Discussion > Do we need a Myst movie?

Do we need a Myst movie?


I've been pondering over this subject for a while now. I think it would be great, a Myst movie, but there's always the distinct possibility that it will be butchered mercilessly by Hollywood. There was, of course, the attempt by the Sci-Fi channel to create a miniseries which never got far enough off the ground to air, but obviously that doesn't count. It really all depends on who would direct. At one point (as in, like, five years ago) Steven Spielberg was interested. Wonder if he still is...
Thoughts, anyone?

reply

I say YES! Definitely there should be a movie. I'd love to see it! With all the information out there from not only the first Myst game, but all of its sequels as well (Riven, Exile, Revelation, Uru), not to mention the 3 books that are out (The book of Ti'ana, the book of Atrus, and the book of D'ni), there's more than enough to make an EXCELLENT movie, or possibly even more than one movie!

reply

Yeeaaah! Someone responded to my post. Yeea-ahem, anyway...sorry, I'm just surprised that anyone responded to this within a year, Myst being as obscure (now) as it is.
What I think would be a great movie situation would be a trilogy of movies based on the three books, and directed by someone who is competent, like Steven Spielberg. That would be fan-tas-tic.

reply

I have to agree, and Spielberg is definitely the man to do it. The question remains as to who would play who. There was a thread on IMDB where people gave there opinions on who they would like to see in the proposed sci-fi channel version. Any ideas? Here’s mine (based on `The book of Ti’ana`).

Aitrus, James Caviezel
Anna, Kiera Knightley
Veovis, Guy Pierce
A’Gaeris, Rutger Hauer

I don’t expect everyone will agree with my choice of actors, on the contrary, I look forward to reading other opinions.

reply

Yes, I'd love a movie about Myst. Probably the best videogame to make a movie about.
All of you who've played some of the games know what I'm talking about when I say that theres loads of information and story in the game. Probably more than all other games. Spielberg would be perfect.

reply

Wow. I like your casting ideas, Rhys, but I'd have probably never thought of them myself. The one problem, I think, is Keira as Anna. Anna is a rather plain girl (in any case, the book never says she's a knockout), and Keira just doesn't quite seem to fit that bill. James Caviezel seems brilliant, and I'm surprised I never thought of that myself, as he's one of my favorite actors. Question, though: Who's Rutger Hauer?

reply

This is Rutger Hauer, http://www.imdb.com/name/nm0000442/
Although the book doesn't say that Anna is a knockout it doesn't say that she isn't either . Besides, IMO she's a very good actress. This is of course just my opinion, I would love to see any ideas that you have for a cast list.

reply

Here's the thing though. Name one good film based on a video game. There are none. They're all crap. Sure, some of the games were crap, but various ones had a good enough source material/story to make good films. But no, it hasn't happened and it probably won't for awhile as long as idiots like Uwe Boll and Paul WS Anderson.

I've always thought that this series could have the potential to make good films. If this ever happens, it is of utmost important (in fact, it should be required!) that Rand Miller and his gang over at Cyan are activelly involved in the filmaking process. Let them handle the story and get a good screenwriter, a good director and good actors and this could be great.

But, if none of this happens, and a film does get made, I will be so ticked off and deeply sadden.

By the way, Mandalay Pictures has this to say on their site:

"Projects in pre-production include: MYST, a 4-hour mini series in development for the SCIFI Channel, based on the best selling CD-ROM game of all time"

This still might be lurking around, but I hope not. I don't want Sci-Fi touch this and I don't want Myst to become a cheap tv show/miniseries.


BTW, look at my screen name. :)

Come on Warner Bros, give us our Blade Runner Special Edition

reply

I agree, Rand Miller and his team must be involved. Hopefully, whoever does it will base any movie(s) on the novels, which will make an incredible trilogy, if so then when they get to 'The Book of D'ni', Rand Miller is really the only person to play Atrus.

So how long did it take you to complete Riven? It took me 7 months.

reply

I can't remember, but yeah, probably along those lines, or a little bit longer, lol. I've beening to pick up the game and play it again, but I just keep putting it off. One of these days though....


Come on Warner Bros, give us our Blade Runner Special Edition

reply

What do you think of Myst 3; Exile? And I can't wait to see Myst 4, apparantley, Sirus and Achenar make a return.

reply

As long as we're talking about this:
Riven was terrible. Well, actually, no, it was a fantastic game, but the puzzles we're incomprehensible (of course, I was only 13 when I played it). Combine very hard puzzles with a very impatient me, and the game only lasted about a month or so: I was referring to cheats all the time, even though it drove me nuts to do that.
And Myst 3 was very good as well; easier puzzles, but it didn't stick with me quite as much as Riven did.

reply

Oh, and another thought that occured to me:
There's a site out there, I think it's called Petitiononline.com, where you can write up an official petition, get signatures, and (I think) turn it in to whichever big cheeses you've directed it at. I'm sure some of you have heard of it.
Anyhoo, us Myst fans should probably take advantage of this....hint, hint.

reply

Sounds like a damm fine idea to me.

reply

Rand Miller is the only one who can play Atrus! And as for Keira Knightley....no, no, no, no, no...if a Myst film ever happens, she shouldn't be let anywhere near it!

reply

I would be more than happy to see a Sci-fi channel miniseries. Their movies are crap, but their miniseries are usually amazing. They've done two great ones based on the Dune books already (Dune and Children of Dune), in addition to Battlestar Galactica and others, so I think they'ed do well with Myst.

reply

I could've sworn that the Myst mini-series was advertised on Sci-Fi Channel and then never shown. From what I heard, it was complete crap...and if Sci-Fi Channel refused to air it...then it must have really sucked.

-----
Looks like you forgot to take your anti-retard pills again.

reply

I'd love to see the years between Book of Atrus and Myst where Atrus constructs his famous island, begins his discoveries of the new ages and is finally has his falling out with his sons. It would be a cinematographic amazement and have a very dark ending.

reply

[deleted]

Interesting choices. Keira might be a bit out of place...James Caviezel would be good but I always thought Paul Giamatti when I saw Atrus for some reason.

We all deserve to die. Even you, Mrs. Lovett, even I.

reply

Carey Mulligan for Anna, GASPARD ULLIEL FOR ATRUS!!!! If only the D'ni had French accents -__-

reply

actually Steven Speildburg is going to direct the movie and its going to star Tom Hanks and is projected to come out in 2007.

reply

I totaLLY AGREE ABOUT THE RAND PLAYING ATRUS AND THE FACT THAT ALL OF THE MOVIES SHOULD BE MADE SEPERATLLY FOR EACH GAME AND BOOK (EXCEPT URU BECAUSE THAT HAD NO REAL STORY LINE RELATED MUCH TO ATRUSES FAMILLY.

this should be the order of them.

1:Book of ti'anna
2:Book of atrus
3:Myst
4:Riven
5:Book of D'ni
6:Exile
7:Revelation
8:End of Ages

That would make an awsome movie seares, and add a little action and keep the myst mysteriousness

reply

I don't think a standard movie would be the best way to film MYST. Usualy these movies must score something in the box office. So the producers may be tempted to put some mainstream action touch to it wich is not my idea of MYST. I stick to miniseries. A well done miniseries would enrich the franchise rather than risking it's integrity. Miniseries can very well be interesting and can appeal to the designated audience.

reply

Am I the only one thinking along these lines? The move should be about the family history of Sirrus, Achenar, Atrus and Catherine. It should be their life on Myst Island, the writing of Myst Island, the writing of The Big 4 Ages from Myst 1, the discovery of people on Stoneship...and of course how Sirrus and Achenar interacted with them and all the horror they caused. Culminating in Atrus being trapped in the green book, the brothers sending Catherine to Ghen on Riven, and the brothers finally getting caught in Spire and Haven.

THAT would make a movie because it's a story as yet only hinted too.

I would love to see that back story.

Course, Rand would have to play Atrus, Sirrus by Gary Oldman, Achenar I'm not sure of, Catherine by I don't know who but someone who can do a good proper English accent.

reply

Casting suggestions from a theatre major with WAY too much free reign on projects. Of course, like all Myst addicts, I would prefer that Rand Miller play Atrus, and that everyone from the games reprise thier roles. I have read in articles that Rand Miller hates acting (please feel free to correct me if I’m wrong) so I have decided to put him out of contetion (and boy did that leave me stewing over who to cast as Atrus!) Cloud- I like the idea of a pre-quel movie, perhaps for them what are not Myst addicts like us. Then we might go into the movies of the games and or novels. As for directors, I’m pulled in three different directions. My first inclination is Tim Burton, just because he seems to have mastered the slightly dream like genre, and his movies (in my oppinion) are some of the best I’ve seen in a while. (Big Fish, Charlie, and Corpse Bride looks good too.) My second inclination would be Steven Spielberg because...well...because he’s Steven Spielberg and good heavens he makes good movies! My third thought, actually, is Kevin Smith, just as long as he swears up, down, sideways, and across, that Jay and Silent Bob will not make an appearance. My other thought on directors runs like this: If you include a prequel, Myst, Riven, Exile, Revelation, Uru, End of Ages, plus the books, thats TEN movies! (I would seriously question if Uru Prime is movie worthy however, it looked pretty bad, so we’ll say nine. Disagree with me if you like.) STILL, even if you remove Uru, its nine movies! What I might be inclined to suggest is that the Mystish Powers That Be, invite nine different directors (well, maybe four or five) to work on the series. Just like with the Harry Potter movies, I’d be missing my family after directing two or three movies in a row too. As for designers, I’d leave that up to the director/producer, except for the fact that I think it should look as much like the games as possible. For the soundtrack, I would suggest first the music from the games, with perhaps some additions to the soundtrack for the movie: “The Stranger’s Theme” or something like that. Artists I would suggest for that song: Danny Elfman, Shakira, Kitaro, and Benoit Jutras (Think Cirque du Soleil, those of you who have seen Cirque shows know what genre of music I mean, and those of you who haven’t, should go see it.)

Enough of my ranting and concept-izing. If I go much further with it, I’ll be sending a letter to Rand Miller suggesting I start directing the series tomorrow! Hmm.....

MYST: THE STORY BEGINS
The Stranger-(See #1 Below)
Atrus Johnathan Frakes
Achenar Liam Neeson
Sirrus Julian Firth
RIVEN: THE SEQUEL TO MYST
The Stranger (See #1 Below)
Atrus Johnathan Frakes
Gehn John Keston/Michael Culver (See Note #1.5)
Young Gehn (See #2) Elijah Wood
Keta/Liera (See #2) Emmy Rossum
Cho Vincente Ramos
Nelah Adrienne Wilkinson
Catherine Julie Dreyfus
Moiety Prisoner Graham Greene
Moeity Scout Deep Roy
Village Guard Deep Roy
Gehn’s Scribe Terrence Hardiman
Jungle Girl Much like Baby Yeesha, just raid a kindergarten
Stranger’s Father (See #2) Tim Robbins
Stranger’s Mother (See #2) Susan Sarandon
MYST III: EXILE
The Stranger (See #1 Below)
Atrus Johnathan Frakes
Catherine Julie Dreyfus
Saavedro Brad Dourif (Of course!)
Baby Yeesha Dude, I don’t know, pick a baby with brown hair!
MYST IV: REVELATION
The Stranger (See #1 Below)
Atrus Johnathan Frakes
Young Yeesha Juliette Gosselin/Dakota Fanning (see #3 below)
Sirrus Julian Firth
Achenar Liam Neeson
Anya Lucy Liu
Moiri/Raeane Vivica A. Fox
Zanika Whoopi Goldberg
Caradell Maggie Smith
Yannin Aishwarya Rai (sp?)

Note #1- My feeling on the Stranger is that his/her (I tend to think of the character as female, but thats probably just because I’m a girl) experience is unique to each gamer, and each gamer has different reactions to situations. So I’d probably never have the Stranger be seen face on or even identified with a name, except “The Stranger.” Even in the credits. I’d probably only have him/her seen from a distance or just a shoulder, a foot, or when turning, a lock of hair. Does that make sense?

Note #1.5- Is John Keston still alive? As the oldest character I have seen to date, and no information readily available, can anyone clue me in? If so he stays, if not, Michael Culver is in as a backup.

Note #2- Riven, in my opinion, would need the most “work” to turn into a movie because some of the puzzles were SO hard and SO nitpicky. So I was thinking of adding flashbacks (and they might continue into Exile) of the Stranger’s family (voiceovers only), as well as when she/he reads Gehn’s journal, she/he might have a flashback or an “imagine” fo what Gehn was, before he became the monster we all know and love. I mean, these two movies (the whole series really) are all about family, so by the time Riven/Exile rolls around, would the Strange be missing his/her family yet? And does he/she ever get back to them? Think about it.

Note #3- Here’s my thoughts on Yeesha. Juliette Gosselin, regardless of how old she actually is, to me, looks older than the ten years old Yeesha supposedly is. On the other hand she is an amazing actress and her portrayal of Yeesha was one of my three favorite performances in the series (the others being Saavedro and Gehn) to date. If the director chooses to make Yeesha look on the young side, I would cast Dakota Fanning. If not, I would, of course, cast Juliette Gosselin. Its a toss up, and would depend on what the director went with.

Love, peace, and Theatre always, Feel free to pick my oppinions to peices, I'm just posting my ideas that I came up with for a casting project as a theatre major. Other oppinions?

M

reply

So I’d probably never have the Stranger be seen face on or even identified with a name, except “The Stranger.” Even in the credits. I’d probably only have him/her seen from a distance or just a shoulder, a foot, or when turning, a lock of hair.
________________________________________________________________________________
I like that idea. We could try to do it from the camera's point of view. What I mean is, we'd be looking at the world throught the Stranger's eye's. If he/she (I like to think the Stranger is a girl too. :-D) needs to use their hands to push a button, pick something up, or push/pull a lever. We could just see an arm come from around the side of the camera. That way, it looks like the Stranger is actually reaching for something.
BTW, you're right about Juliette being older than ten. I remember looking her up in the IMDb, and it said she was 13. It may have been 14, I'll have to double-check. Dakota Fanning would also be a good choice. She's such a great actress, and as cute as could be! She'd have to dye her hair brown, since there don't seem to be any blondes in the family.

edit: I just thought of a problem. According to RAWA, trap books are "not canon". The trap books in Myst and Riven were made up just to make the story more interesting. Apparently, in Myst, all the Stranger did was read journals, and that was how he/she decided who was guilty. But if we want to remain true to the games, we'd have to include trap books in Myst 1 and 2, but not have them in Myst 4. How would we explain that to the audience?
Only poor people are crazy. The rich are eccentric. -Lionel Luthor (Smallville)

reply

I like that idea of casting the stranger. Persoanlly, I think only a handful of directors could ever pull it off, or even if audiences would accept it. The response to the Doom film would clue us in a little better, i think.
Honestly, I do not think Liam Neeson is the man to play Achenar, though. He isn't sadistic enough, IMO. I would go for someone with a little more brutish crazy experience.

reply

Honestly, I don't think that making a movie from the actual games would be a good idea. I'm not dissing the idea, a Myst movie would be great, but I would rather leave the identity of the stranger a mystery...

But if they made a movie based off the books, now there's a good idea.

I don't have a much idea for the casting roles but i do have a few suggestions:

Book Of Atrus

Gehn (Adult): Jason Isaacs
Anna: Glenn Close
Mute Slave: Brad Garrett
Salar: Emily Browning (though this may change)

Book Of Ti'ana

Aitrus: Christain Bale or Jim Caviezal
Anna (young): Amanda Byrnes
Veovis: Ian Somerhalder (Lost) or Cillian Murphy

Book Of D'ni

Atrus: Kurt Russell

So far that's all I got. But I know that no actor wouldn't appear in the Myst movies more than once.

As for the director, I don't mean to sound self-centered but when I read the books, I can't help but think I'll be the one who'll direct them.

reply

The perfect person to play Gehn would be Malcom McDowell.

reply

Yes but not based on the games, rather on the books. I think books provide a better plot for a movie.

reply

I think that another good idea for a Myst movie would take place after everything has happend, more around the timeline of Uru. That could work with the plot following a group of explorers in D'ni or even the discovery of D'ni by humans in the 80s. There were many other ages eluded to in Uru and its expansions. So there could even introduce new peoples still alive in those ages. That would probably be the best way for a Myst movie to be made. Use the concept but possibly not the original story. Although it would be interesing to make the novels into a movie. Brian-778, your ideas are also very good. A history of the family would be awesome.

Oh and Spielburg may be a good idea but there may be others to get as well.

reply

Everyone is forgetting the most obvious choice for Gehn. Patrick Stewart looks exactly like Gehn is described in the books and even looks like the actor who plays him in Riven. He's one of the movst under-rated actors in hollywood. His voice, style of acting, presense on the screen is perfect for Gehn.

reply

[deleted]

[deleted]

[deleted]

[deleted]

personal opinion is that you have an unknown director who is a dedicated fan of the series direct so you don't run as much a risk of "hoolywoodization"

as for story i have an idea that i'm working on for Myst so please tell me what you think.

-A young man and woman stumble uppon Myst, a shabby book that transports them to a strange island where they must help two men trapped in books by finding pages around the island and the adjoning "ages". But when the pages come to life and form different personalities, the two heroes must decide if they should trust the brothers, or another strange man trapped in a book.

reply

That's a good idea. It shouldn't be first person. Look at the "success" of the DOOM move (that was first-person).

reply

[deleted]

the BOOK, (of atrus), can without doubt be made into a beautiful movie.

"You ever dance with the devil by the pale moonlight?"
M. Night Shyamalan, Christopher Nolan rock!

reply

I love your idea for a movie version of Myst. When I first heard of the possibility of a Myst movie, I thought that was what they should do. I do think the games should be made into movies(esp. Riven and Exile). I don't know if the books work, but I haven't read them so I'll need to look into that. Also, I haven't played Revelation, End of Ages, and Uru, but that was because I only recently got a new(i.e. non-Windows 98) computer, so until now, I could only play Myst and Riven (yeah, it was that old.). Still, I'll eventually pick them up and play them.

reply

Plain NO.

I'm a huge fan of all Myst games (My favorite is Riven which is the best game that has ever been made IMO), and I think that they are perfect as they are - computer games. The slide-show and point-and-click system which was first introduced by Myst back in '93 is the best method for those games. I think I'm one of the "conservatives" here - I was offended even that Myst V: EoA was 3D realtime. The slide-show system is so inseparable from Myst that I think it cannot exist without it. So just imagine to yourself how I would feel if it will make it's way to a completely different media. Moreover, I am also very picky when it comes to movies. I hate corny storyline and bad acting. The Myst franchise is a treasure that has been boiled for 12 years. Just think what can happen if some Hollywood studio will take over this project with all the bad stuff that can be going on there, will hire a mediocre director with mediocre script, a director which has nothing to do with Myst emotionally or knowledge-wise, will want to make some grandiose movie with nothing inside. It sounds like a disaster. They will want to make it a huge block-buster and you will be disgusted by "what they made of my favorite game". Just imagine all the fights between the production, the director, the developers (Miller Bro's, and Cyan), all the copyright mess. Not to mention that three different companies made the 5 games. A recipe for a flop.

Even the past is not on our side - look at all other games adapted as movies...
Even if spielberg would direct it won't be good. You cannot make a good movie out of it no matter what. You love it as Myst, the mysterious game, on an island, with puzzles, and ages, and silence with no people to talk to, with planetarium, library, and two books with two eccentric brothers in them - not as a motion picture.

reply

I've been watching this post for several months now and I've looked at all the posts written for the Myst series in general. i'd like to share a few thoughts on the subject.

First off, one of the big things i'm seeing on the posts is the clear fact that over the past few years, video games have not been adapted very well to the film format. I'll admit that the first Resident Evil had some hopes in the film industry, but overall, the films have sucked. The question becomes though, why? Why do video games not translate so well to the big screen when they've done so well with the consumers. The big thing is the lack of a good writen screenplay. Let's face it, all the video game movies we've seen hit theaters have been retooled to a different storyline shwoing us the video game characters in a completely new way that we don't find appealing. Examples would be Bloodrayne, Super Mario Brothers, and Mortal Kombat. Actually, correction on Mortal Kombat, all it did was add a story to the gameplay. In any case, the screenplays sucked.

Second thing, I actually know someone who is looking to write a screenplay for Myst and, unconfirmed at the moment but, has written up a treatment for a Myst film that stays true to the story. He hopes that if it goes well, he'll do a screenplay for each of the games. Storyline will be the same BUT it will be told from the Stranger's point of view with a little added flair to accomadate the stranger's place in the storyline. Things like puzzles and such will not be evident in his work except where it is necessary.

Whoever had that idea for the petition online thing, I say go ahead and do it if not already done. Also, any additional news on who has the Myst rights and where its at right now would be helpful in the long run for everyone.

Last thing, I like the way the video games to movies thing is going right now. we have Hitman, Splinter Cell, and Prince of Persia being talked about and I can only hope that sooner or later, Halo will join its ranks as soon as the (censored for post reasons)

reply

[deleted]

M. Night Shyamalan could pull it off, his style works with that of the game, I really enjoyed Lady In The Water, it had aspects that reminded me of Myst in certain ways.



'follow him, he speaks in sentences....'

reply

A movie based on Myst has the potential to be a masterpiece if the project were to be in the hands of the right people. But that's what it's always boiled down to with all these video games to movie translations. Resident Evil could've been fantastic if George E Romero was allowed to make it seeing as zombie movies are his speciality. But those producers were too stupid to realise that and insisted it on making it a 15 certificate and quite happy for Paul Anderson to have characters using flying kicks on zombies which of course we all did to Ramon Salazar and Lord Saddler on Resident Evil 4. Good god!!

Anyway, back to Myst. I actually think it would be better to have a similar idea to the first game where there's very few speaking parts but a story hidden across in different ages waiting to be uncovered. It just had that atmosphere and magical scenery which were the key elements to the game. The feeling of dread with the haunting music. The main character should be a mysterious and perhaps cool character where hardly anything is given away about his past. I'd love to see a few puzzles that the main character has to solve and the audience can join in trying to figure it out.

Actually this could be right up David Lynch's street.

reply

I think what needs to happen is that the books need to made into a movie. There is a plot line to Myst but not a very good one. Because you are the only one and like it has been said before it would mostly be silence. You couldnt really do anything with it. So I think that we should concentrate on the books and less of the game.

reply

I like the idea of the stranger character, but he/she must be a character just like Atrus and the rest and must fit into the storyline. He or she must be used by Atrus to help him to accomplish his goals.

Here is my idea: The movie starts with a teenage boy and his friends going out into the mountains on a camping trip. He wanders off and accidently fell into a cave. He didn't hurt himself and start to figure out how to get out off this mess. Unfortunately he can't get out and start to explore the cave he is in for an exit. Then he stumbles upon this weird ancient book that is stuck between rocks. Bewildered, he removes the book to see the engravings: "MYST" on it. He breaks the lock on the book and opens it. His is startled to find that the front page have some weird glowing panel on it and the other page have some ancient looking language (D'ni)! Out of curiosness he touches the panel with is finger tip. With a horibble scream he get sucked into the page.

Now this is where the real epic story starts!

reply

I too would love to see a Myst movie(s)! I totally agree - would love to seem them based on the books!

reply

[deleted]

Yeah, just make a movie out of book one. I shouldn't be a hit, that would just be annoying:p, the miller brothers should be the actors, and there should be a real myst island build for the movie. But all those demands are impossible :P

reply

Myst, Riven & Exile are some of my most treasured games/stories, i wholeheartedly support the idea of a Myst Movie, but based around (not on) the games

reply

Well, nothing is certain, but it seems we ARE getting a movie based on the Myst Universe.

The project formely known as Project Passage, and currently (and tentatively) as Myst The Motion Picture, has begun since 2006, and apparently has CYAN's support. The people who run it are called The Mysteriacs. (more info on them is available on the official site)

The movie is said to be based on a novel -probably one of the MYST novels, and most possibly The Book of Ti'Ana.

Rand Miller called it "an unorthodox approach to making a Myst movie" and has provided a foreword regarding the movie (again available on the official site).

Official site (and production blog): http://mystmovie.com/

reply

I'm feeling kinda good about this given whose making it. I think if hollywood attempted to do they'd really change a lot of things to appeal to a mass audience, to the point where it wouldn't feel like the games or the books. So I like that it's being done by this smaller group who seem to be making it just for the fans, and Rand Miller's direct approval gives me some hope.

reply

I'm looking forward to see a MYST Movie, but don't let anybody from Hollywood do it. Myst is too "different". It can'nt be made by any big, mainstream studio. It should be an independent movie. The most important thing is the atmosphere. Myst movie shouldn't have any explosions or crowded scenes (not more than 5 people in a frame). It should have a good story, few but strong characters, wonderful machines and breathtaking scenery. It could be made in a way similar to Sin City or 300 (I mean the way you use CGI combined with live action). All we need is vision. It can't be a big budget action movie. It has to be a work of art.

reply

[deleted]

Hmm, I'm not sure how I feel about that. I could definitely see a Myst movie being good, but I can also see it very, very bad. Firstly, Cyan's original intention was for Stranger to be a faceless, nameless person. You were supposed to imagine yourself as Stranger. Would this be ruined by a Hollywood face being slapped onto the character? Secondly, they might pull another typical Hollywood move and overdo the backstory and make it extremely cheesy. I think that the backstory should be a highlight...it shouldn't be totally dominant. I think the mystery of Myst and the fact that you're on this island and you have no idea what to do at first is really great and it's sort of ruined if you throw in a bunch of stuff about Aster and Catherine and their sons and what not.

So what I'm saying is that a movie could work, but there's way too big of a chance that it wouldn't.

We all deserve to die. Even you, Mrs. Lovett, even I.

reply

Hell of an idea! Too bad Richard Pryor is dead, they could have him as the main guy. Let's add Cheech & Chong to it, as well. I'd see it‼

_______________

My iMDB profile http://www.imdb.com/name/nm4297325/?ref_=fn_al_nm_1

reply