MovieChat Forums > Sib (1999) Discussion > The symbolism of an apple (slight spoile...

The symbolism of an apple (slight spoilers)


At least one of the reviews questions the significance of the apple. To me it seemed obvious in many ways as to what the apples might mean. Firstly, as an orchard fruit they are probably exotic in Iran - I don't know this for sure - but I imagined they were a rarity, hence the sisters' fascination with them. Secondly, as a religious symbol they are about temptation and a 'fall from grace'. They seem to be the most tempting of the new objects to which the sisters are introduced. They signify the 'fall from grace' of sisters and father who stray from the mother's demand that they remain an insular unit locked away from their society. The dad gives them money to go off and buy apples, which is a significant step as he's so poor. Then he later goes off with them to buy watches! The apples are, therefore, the most significant step in his process of accepting what the social worker tells him he must do for his daughters.

The film was most touching and I felt as much for mum and dad as I did the two young girls. The poverty was shocking but the sense of community and care towards the family from the neighbours and curiosity of the neighbourhood children was optimistic and warming. As well as funny. It's amazing that the director was only 17 when she made this film, which is very mature in its treatment of the characters and situation.

Keep silent unless what you are going to say is more important than silence.

reply

The girls are obviously mentally challenged, as even children locked away would be able to at least communicate. The mother forcing the father to lock his girls away while he was out was probably a good decision, as boys their age can be quite cruel and take advantage of any situation. If they lived on a farm the girls would probably have the run of the place.
The way he had to bring the apple to within a couple of inches from his face to see what it was, suggests he was near to blindness himself.
I don't know how old the mother was, but for the father to have two children at such an old age must have been difficult with the mother being blind. He did well to bring them up so healthy. No excuse not to let them go to school though.

reply

nice analysis








so many movies, so little time

reply