MovieChat Forums > Pariah (1999) Discussion > Questions about Pariah

Questions about Pariah


Is it based on a true story?

reply

who cares?? a movie this bad doesnt deserve any more thought than utter disgust at its hideousness.

reply

There is a review from a German Website - the link is on the External Reviews section of IMDB. Here is the review:

Many films have tried to have a look at the deluded belief of neo-Nazis, or to study the mechanisms of relevant organizations. Ironically, almost all of these works (represented mostly by "Romper Stomper" and "American History X" are considered as exemplary examples) to cult films feature a main character (played by Edward Norton in "American History X", Derek Vinyard), become icons for many neo-Nazis, albeit a fictional. Ironically, this misinterpretation finds these characters becoming beloved instead of daring a sober approach to the racist ideology, who they really are and paying attention to the seduction and fascination for vulnerable people. The danger in those films is that the main protagonist are eloquent and charismatic leaders. This characterization leads to the danger of becoming attractive, which can all too easily make this lifestyle attractive. All this has but little in common with "Pariah", and to illustrate how significant the differences are in the characters and plot construction. Randolph Kret pursued other goals and meets the phenomenon of right-wing radicalism in a completely different way.

Kret could hardly be clearer in Pariah: The skins are already in a prison - a prison that deprives them of any chance for the future, social isolation means, and can basically only grow in the further hatred. The same authentic dialogues written in the vernacular, "Menace II Society", which describes a similar urban nightmare. This does not lead to a revenge catharsis, no conciliatory "justice" causes, only underscores the relentless nature of this dark and uncomfortable film. This is a film made to make people think – the goal is not to make the characters attractive, but to show the destruction this lifestyle leads to and the stain it leaves on the human soul.
Von Marco Siedelmann (German Film Critic)
Hard Sensations (German Website for Hardboiled films)

This review sums up the point of the film - it's not to create a seductive character but to show you the raw anger that permeates society.

reply

Yes it was. In real life, the man who became a skinhead apparently did jail time as well.

reply

Based on real events. In the Sacramento and San Francisco area.
The director also worked with Portland Police and Reno Police
in gang details on skinhead cases. I saw him speak at the
San Francisco film festival with some actors and one of the
people portrayed in the film.

reply

[deleted]

[deleted]

Very true, racial skinheads would see it as demeaning to waste their seed on a mongrel.

reply

[deleted]

Half these damn skinheads probably have some black ancestry themselves, they just won't admit it, or were never told----they would probably kill themselves if they found out, since their brains were crammed with that white supremacy bull****. Another thing that makes me laugh is that the whole "skinhead" thing---just being bald--was stolen from working-class black Jamaicans who emigrated to England in the late '50/early '60's---a lot of those racist idiots either don't know or wouldn't even admit that's true---ha ha ha!

reply

Yes - the entire look of Skinheads is "borrowed"... Which makes the hate they feel - sad. As they have borrowed from cultures that they claim to despise...

reply

[deleted]

[deleted]

Actually a hate crime by the definition of the law is any crime that is carried out with a motivation of racial, gender, or sexual orientation bias. You seem to be pro skinhead greg, so I'm pretty sure there were too many big words in there for you. Sorry

reply

[deleted]

[deleted]

[deleted]

Hi Charlot1969 -

Yes the film is actually based on three events threaded together to make one story. The filmmakers brother and girlfriend were the victims of an attack in Northern California after a concert. The producers brother was the victim of a "gay bashing" in San Francisco and the filmmaker spent a year with two police departments profiling Neo-Nazi's for the film.

reply