Dancing Guy..wtf??


seriously

reply

[deleted]

[deleted]

If you had read the book you'd know that he did an outstanding job recreating Cormac McCarthy's award winning novel, you couldn't be farther from the truth. Remember that thing called reading?

Also, that dancing man was *beep* ridiculous.

reply

In certain places and certain cultures, people have a tendency to take an interest in, and feel empathy toward others, even complete strangers. This is fairly common in Mexico and Ireland. Probably other places as well. Many film makers and writers seem to be conscious of it, as it has been portrayed in a number of works. People seem to see and care about the little joys and sorrows in the lives of others, even strangers. If you’ve never experienced it, I suppose it might seem strange or intrusive. The “dancing man” just happens to be present when John Grady Cole makes the phone call to Alejandra. He seems to sense the gravity of the phone call, and typically can’t resist waiting to see how it turns out. The intensity of young love moves him, as it moves many. The telephone conversation (at least Cole’s side of it) progresses, in a few short moments from desperation and longing, to a sort of triumph and quiet joy at the prospect of being reunited (if only for a while) with his love. The older man senses this, and does a little dance as if to congratulate Cole on his success, and to share in his happiness a little.

reply

bravo, well done

reply

The man isn't actually dancing! It is the fact that John Grady had convinced his "soul mate" Alejanda to meet him which made him ecstatic and happier than life. In his mind everything was sunny and brilliant with color and everyone was smiling and dancing. He was going to see Alejandra and he was just overwhelemd with happiness. The next shot the man is not dancing he is still giving him the evil eye but you can still hear the dancing. It's because John Grady is in love and when you are in love nothing can bring you down and everything is perfect and you are as happy as you have ever been. he was staring at John Grady, giving him a dirty look, but what John Grady sees is a man as happy FOR him as he is for himself. Haven't you ever been in love before? It's a beautiful feeling... and I thought the scene was brilliant.

reply

Reading? What's that? Younger generations today would rather just go see the latest mindless CGI movie.

reply

I read. I read a lot. I didn't know it was a requirement to read a book before seeing a movie.

reply

im glad some people responded to my original post..that scene just kind of seemed unnecessary seeing as its no where in the book

reply

The book mentions nothing of it, in fact, in my opinion, the film brought life to the story more than the book.....anywho, I think the dancing man just represents the happiness he feels being able to reunite with the girl.

reply