MovieChat Forums > The Rage: Carrie 2 (1999) Discussion > Could Rachel have been male?

Could Rachel have been male?


Do you think the movie would have worked if the 'outcast' character of Rachel had been male?

I don't think a male "Carrie" would work because moviegoers don't sympathise with male 'victims' the same way they sympathise with female ones.

reply

[deleted]

I think it would, instead. It would be a nice new twist.

Doug Roberts: What do they call it when you kill people?
The Towering Inferno

reply


They would sympathize if Jason London's Jesse was the
main lead in the third one.But it would have to take place
after or during college.Jason stopped playing teenage boys
only nine years ago.

reply

Nope. Female leads work better in horror films. Male leads don't usually work very well. For example: A Nightmare on Elm Street 2

Lets put a SMILE on that face!

reply

It wouldn't have worked if Rachel was a male because men are carriers of telekinetic power but only woman can display it...

LOLFAG! Cyanide & Happiness

reply

Beautiful transsexual killers are awesome!

reply

I don't think it would have worked. During the humiliation scenes he'd have come off as a whinny puss who just needs to stand up for himself. Than when he snaps and kills everyone at the end he'd have come off more like the way the media portrayed those Columbine kids.

reply

Wasn't it said in one of the movies that the male is only the carrier of the gene? I don't know if that's the only way, just something I remembered (maybe incorrectly..)

reply

[deleted]

it would be ridiculous to claim that either the original carrie film or book insisted upon a rule that telekinetic powers are only available to females. There's no real or justified authority... and even if there was? This is fantasy/horror! You can create whatever adjustment you want. You can rewrite the rules, this isn't reality.

Also, this movie sucks.

reply

They should call the third one 'Barrie' or 'Corey' and have a guy as the lead...

reply

I would have liked to see a male version of Carrie

reply

I thought you said rachel was a man and i was seriously thinking about it. She could be a hermaphrodite.

reply