Live action Macross film


Now that ADV Films has the rights to Macross, do you think ADV films should make a live action Macross and if yes, who should direct, do the CGI effects, etc.? For me, it's these choices

1. Hideaki Anno
2. Tim Burton
3. Peter Jackson
4. Joel Schumacher
5. Lexi Alexander
6. Alejandro Amenábar
7. George Lucas
8. Stephen Hopkins
9. Alfonso Cuarón
10. Fernando Sariñana

CGI Effects: WETA

Music by Shirly Walker

If I can mix Code Lyoko, Marvel and DC together.

reply

[deleted]

If you want a top gun basis you'll need Tony Scott,but he's not been really good lately.get his older brother instead.

reply

I think Macross could be Tony Scott's chance to redeem himself.

If I can mix Code Lyoko, Marvel and DC together.

reply

Scott usually does revenge sotries with crappy dialogue nowadays and with bad flash cuts with strange colors all around,trust me,see Domino its not very good,though you will see Keira Knightly with some of her clothes off:)

reply

Just as long as he doesn't americanise Macross I'll be fine with him directing.

If I can mix Code Lyoko, Marvel and DC together.

reply

Um,Tony Scott does alot of American movies it seems obvious he'd make it into an American movie,as well would your other choices,if you wnat an American or at least a big shot director they will Americanise it no matter they don't want a bomber trust me.

reply

Since ADV Films owns Macross and tehy might make a live action movie, I bet ADV films won't allow Tony Scott to americanise Macross.

If I can mix Code Lyoko, Marvel and DC together.

reply

If they want An international Macross then why bother choosing Tony scott anyway.

reply

It depends if ADV Films chose him and tells him what they're going for and hopefully Tony Scott willg o for it and hopefully he'll understand the Macross.

If I can mix Code Lyoko, Marvel and DC together.

reply

Tony as well as any diretcor from America or mostly works in America won't do it,they want it to be a blockbuster hit in the states,and if ADV filsm actually wants to go for an American verison of it,they would wnat a filmmaker who makes the most,lately Tony hasn't made the most.
An American Diretcor(tony isn't American but he works for the US)+Japanise Project NOT released in states=NEVER GOING TO HAPPEN.

reply

ADV Films will release an international film in the states worked with Memoirs of a Geisha.

If I can mix Code Lyoko, Marvel and DC together.

reply

Only Memoires of a Geisha was a book made and released in the steas,Macross wasn't,it was shipped ot the states.

reply

Now it is, thanks to ADV Films, they completely redubbed Macross and since ADV Films is making the live action EVA movie, it might be possible that ADV films might do Macross next.

If I can mix Code Lyoko, Marvel and DC together.

reply

I'm not Americanizing Macross, I'm just putting in the character names like this: "Macross name (Robotech name)"
"Macross" (2008)
Cast
Daniel Radcliffe as Hikaru Ichijyo (Rick Hunter)
Emma Watson as Lynn Minmei
Kay Panabaker as Misa Hayase (Lisa Hayes)
Rupert Grint as Roy Focker (Roy Fokker)
Ashanti as Claudia LaSalle (Claudia Grant)
Skandar Keynes as Hayao Kakizaki (Ben Dixon)
Chris Rankin as Maximilian Jenius (Max Sterling)
Jean Reno as Captain Bruno J. Global (Captain Henry Gloval)
Katie Leung as Milia Fallyna (Miriya)
Anna Popplewell as Vanessa Laird (Vanessa Leeds)
Chisaki Hama as Kim Kabirov (Kim Young)
Bonnie Wright as Shammy Milliome (Sammie Porter)
Patrick Stewart as Vrlitwhai Kridanik (Breetai)
Charles Adler as Excedol Folmo (Exedore)
William Moseley as Lynn Kaifun (Lynn Kyle)
Carlo Giuffre as Admiral Takashi Hayase (Admiral Donald Hayes)
Tilda Swinton as Lap Lamiz (Azonia)
Patrick Swayze as Quamzin Kravshera (Khyron Kravshera)
Kevin Spacey as Boddole Zer (Dolza)
Directors
Clint Eastwood and Carl Macek
Distributors
Warner Bros. Pictures, Lions Gate Films, Artisan Entertainment, and PBS Pictures
Rating
PG for sci-fi action violence and brief nudity (MPAA); 12A for a brief image of nudity (BBFC)
A.K.A.
Robotech (USA)
Robotech: The Macross Saga (USA: DVD title)
Countries: China / Japan / UK
Languages: Chinese / English / Japanese

>:(
"Are you trying to say "capisce"? Because it hurts my ears the way you say it."

reply

Dude, even if you said you're americanising Macross, you just put in your U.S. cast while a live action Macross movie should have an international cast and ADV films is the only company that can make this sort of movie I mean PBS doing Macross?

If I can mix Code Lyoko, Anime, Freddy, Jason, Alien, Predator, Marvel and DC together.

reply

[deleted]

I said I wasn't Americanizing the damn thing! Art thou deaf?

>:(
"Are you trying to say "capisce"? Because it hurts my ears the way you say it."

reply

and i really dont wanna see the cast of harry potter in any other movie together other then harry potter

i mean come on kay pananbaker,rupert gint, emma watson and daniel radcliff in the lead roles UMNN NO!!! they all would be kids from like 14 to 18!!!!

you all might as well get disney on board and borrow all the disney channel kids!! cause god knows disney cornered the market on popular child actors!!

what part of the story you trying to tell the very beginning???

personally id be looking for an international cast between 17 and 23, just to keep it more realistic.

plus as long as macross is it would be a hack job to tell a story thats about 2 hours in length. they came they kicked our ass, we scared ther *beep* out of em and showed em a new life they joined us the end!

reply

This movie will never work. Robotech can't be done as a film because there is just too much in formation to try to cram into a 2 to 4 hour film. I highly doubt that the movie will even be up to 3 or 4 hours. It'll probably be more like 1 hour and 30 minutes to 2 hours, 2 hours and 30 minutes at the most. The movie will be missing so much. I think it would work better as a live action T.V. series. That way, every episode can cover everything that happened in an updated version of the 1980s anime television series. Every season would be identical to the anime episodes except for some minor changes in the story to vamp it up and not make it seem so dated. A lot of the stuff in Robotech is even outdated more than just stuck in its own time period. Like the fact that no one has a cell phone. It doesn't really seem important but trust me, little things like that make all the difference when you are trying to present some realism in your escapist fantasies. Then we have the ridiculously '80s plot device of a global thermonuclear war between the U.S.A. and their allies, and the U.S.S.R. and their allies in the year 19xx, I mean come on. There is a lot of work that needs to be done before a live action Robotech project can even get done. Plus, there is the whole Hollywood issue. You have a conundrum. You're damned if you do and you're damned if you don't. If you want Robotech to be sold to an American audience, it's going to need a lot of money, and only the richest directors, executive producers and producers can afford to spend a lot of money to get everything looking like it should. The writers of course will have to Americanize it because the most powerful people in Hollywood are racist and they are not going to give the Japanese more credit than Americans. They will probably want a big name Hollywood actor and actress to be the two leads in the film, so you can forget about getting a Japanese guy to play Rick. Now, that's only if the film is going for the Hollywood treatment. Big bucks, big effects, crappy story. That's just the way it is. If the movie is a Japanese film, you are going to wind up with a smart plot. But a strong story won't make a film make millions. The effects in Japan are decent, but not for the spoiled rotten action movie fans who must have perfection. Most of these people aren't interested in a plot. They just want explosions, fight scenes, and breasts. If you try to make them think, the movie will either bomb or not make as much money as the studio hoped for. Japan will never meet these expectations because their effects are substandard to Hollywood's. And in Robotech, you can't settle for substandard. Plus, like I said before, the U.S. is a racist society. No studio will take a Japanese film seriously. Not to the point where they consider it better than an American film. That's never gonna happen, even if the film is superior to anything in the States. So you got accuracy, good plot, substandard effects versus inaccuracy, bad plot, really good effects. Take your pick. But, remember what I said. It's a conundrum. You're damned if you do and you're damned if you don't. But if you must insist on making Robotech a movie instead of a well thought out, well planned series, then by all means. Go ahead. Make your decision...and live with it.

reply

The idea of a live action movie sounds great but the problem with that are the financial considerations as you said.... I think only a big hollywood studio could afford the project but it would result in a crappy-story version of the original... very american-audience oriented. You know, for example having leading roles played by young actors comming straight from the TV (the O.C. or any other stupid series of the moment)... that would be a great shame with this story which I belive is more like a romance drama inserted in an epic Sci-Fi and War plot, and not just a regular action-adventure type of film.

What I really would like to see (and I'm guessing also most of the original fans who are not teenagers anymore would like too) its a Movie that could capture the essence of the original japanese story, and a group of young actors (not teenagers) with good talent on acting dramatic stories, sort of what Tobey Maguire has done for Spiderman, and a Film director with more sense of the artistic things and not that much of the commercial ones. Otherwise the whole thing would just end on that crap is being produced constantly (sort of Top gun meets any-stupid-space-film-ever-since-the-90's)

reply

Actually the US/USSR war was on Robotech ... not in Macross; though there was some kind of "anti-UN" war that happened between the 1999 and 2009 time frame. One of the consequences was the genocide of the entire Mars base population by the "anti-UN" faction, which is why the place is deserted when the SDF1 arrives there.

I would keep the Japanese story/version, but I do really think that "Rick Hunter" should keep that name (at least in the International Release) as it is how he was really known outside of Japan.

Kind of like the entire M. Bison/Balrog/Vega switcheroo...

reply

Macross is not Robotech.

I wish they make a Robotech movie and see it fail miserably.
Its going to be laughable when watching the main character saying
"Geez we ran out of Protoculture!" or "Lets get more Flowers of Life! We need to create more Protoculture!"

reply

Rights to make a live action Robotech are with Warner Bros. Rumor has it that Tobey Mcguires production company will make it. One thing that Tobey should do before he starts is to watch "Macross:Do You Remember Love?". Alot of very important elements of the story are seen in this two hour movie. Better dialog, and less downtime would make the Robotech movie much better than DYRL. So, if anyone has the balls, send Tobey a copy of DYRL (You can only find the subtitled version, best to download it and give it to him). Its one of the things you fans can do to make sure this movie is high quality. Also, its probably not a bad idea to explain what protoculture is, though it might not be that important.

reply

There's no way the upcoming "Robotech" movie could be better or even as good as Do you remember love? and Warner Bros. would copy it, Big West would notice.

reply

[deleted]