MovieChat Forums > Cruel Intentions (1999) Discussion > Recast "Cruel Intentions" 90s style

Recast "Cruel Intentions" 90s style


I'll start:

Kathryn Merteuil ... Marla Sokoloff

Sebastian Valmont ... James Franco

Annette Hargrove ... Kirsten Dunst

Cecile Caldwell ... Amber Benson

Ronald Clifford ... Cuba Gooding Jr.


Your turn folks.

reply

Why would you recast it 90's style, when it's already a 90's movie?🐭

reply

Because I thought recasting "Cruel Intentions" worked better, having actors and actresses within the same era. Teen movies were different back then, and yet, still interchangeable. They were trendy, comedic, karmic, and they were generational. I listed some stars from then, I feel duplicates "Cruel Intentions" on and offscreen, and I know one way or the other, they're not alone, in their former Young Hollywood days in the 90s.

reply

Kathryn - Marley Shelton
Sebastian - Leo Dicaprio
Annette - Jennifer Love Hewitt
Cecile - Larisa Oleynik
Ronald - Usher

reply

Nice list. I really like your casting for Sebastian and Annette. Leonardo DiCaprio and Jennifer Love Hewitt were two of the hottest young stars in the 90s, and they would've been a dream come true as an item in any movie.

reply

How about recasting it 2015 style?

Gee, the lack of humility before nature that's being displayed here, uh.. staggers me.

reply

I figured I could hit closer to home, using the actual decade of the movie. I also never see anyone recast older movies within their time, so i'm trying a different approach.

Don't get me wrong though. I have thought about a 2015 remake, as you can see down below.


Cruel Intentions cast 2015:

Kathryn Merteuil ... Michelle Trachtenberg

Sebastian Valmont ... Robert Pattinson

Annette Hargrove ... Elizabeth Olsen

Cecile Caldwell ... Ali Cobrin

Ronald Clifford ... Tristan Wilds

reply

Kathryn Merteuil ... Michelle Trachtenberg

Sebastian Valmont ... Robert Pattinson


Haha, the Bella and Edward that almost was? I like it, Michelle has talent for playing a villain.

reply

Michelle has talent for playing a villain.


No doubt about it. She's really grown up over the years, and she's taken pride in it. Forget Twilight. She had Buffy, and now she can take over for Sarah Michelle Gellar in a Cruel Intentions remake.

reply

Jennifer Love Hewitt as Katheryn
Skeet Ulrich as Sebastian
Alicia Silvertone as Annette
Marley Shelton as Cecile
Nicolas Brendon as Blaine
Freddy Prince Jrn as Greg

Obviously, I was answering the original post.

reply

2015 Style - this will be good - my knowledge of modern teen culture is limited at best, but here goes :

Sasha Pieterse as Katheryn
Ian Harding as Sebastian
Ashley Benson as Annette
Lucy Hale as Cecile
Keegan Allen as Blaine
Tyler Blackburn as Greg

Obvioulsy, Janel Parrish, Troian Bellisario and Shay Mitchell would have to be given minor roles somewhere.

Yeah, as I said VERY Limited knowledge of Modern Teen Culture.....they could always call it PRETTY CRUEL INTENTIONS!

reply

Yeah, as I said VERY Limited knowledge of Modern Teen Culture.


Don't worry about it. You've already fulfilled my thread in your other post, and you still know more than I do about modern teen culture. Both of your posts are good.

reply

Obviously, I was answering the original post.


Yes you did, and you also went the extra mile in casting, which I commend you for doing. The more teen stars from then, the better.

reply

2015


Katheryn- Mila Kunis or Leighton Meester
Sebastian- Ed Westwick, Shia Labeouf or Tom Felton
Anette- Elizabeth Olsen or Evan Rachel Wood
Cecile- Emma Stone or Abigail Breslin
Ronald- Alfred Enoch or Michael B Jordan


Whiches ones out of each 2 would you choose? I can't decide. Or 3 in Sebastian's Case.

reply

Katheryn- Mila Kunis
Sebastian- Tom Felton
Anette- Elizabeth Olsen
Cecile- Abigail Breslin
Ronald- Michael B Jordan

reply

I also know very little of modern culture, so...

2015:
1. Kathryn - Naya Rivera
2. Sebastian - Jeremy Irvine
3. Annette - Emma Stone
4. Cecile - Chloe Grace Moretz

2000s:
1. Kathryn - Rachel McAdams
2. Sebastian - Chad Michael Murray
3. Annette - Anne Hathaway
4. Cecile - Alexis Bledel

reply

For Buffy/Angel fans:


Kathryn Merteuil ... Julie Benz

Sebastian Valmont ... David Boreanaz

Annette Hargrove ... Sarah Michelle Gellar

Cecile Caldwell ... Mercedes McNab


You guys get the message.

reply

It would hard for them to be better than the actual cast but I could see James Van Der Beek as Valmont, Katie Holmes or Natalie Portman as Cecile, Kirsten Dunst as Annette and Usher as Ronald. Kathryn is the hardest but maybe Rachael Leigh Cook.

reply

You're right to place Katie Holmes with Cecile. Natalie Portman gives Kirsten Dunst a run for her money as a recast for Annette. They were both becoming "It" girls or "dream" girls back then.

reply

Kathryn- Rose McGowan
Sebastian- James Van Der Beek
Annette- Melissa Joan Hart
Cecile- Keri Lyn Pratt
Ronald- Omar Epps
Greg- Matthew Lilard
Blaine- Eddie Kaye Thomas

reply

no way Marla Sokoloff is playing Kathryn... no way

reply