MovieChat Forums > Urgh! A Music War Discussion > Best concert movie ever?

Best concert movie ever?


I just learned about this film for the first time on culturecloud (http://www.culturecloud.com/Articles/00001639/Best_concert_film.aspx) and some on there are calling "Urgh" the best concert movie ever?

reply

It's too uneven to be the best concert film ever. That distinction goes either to Stop Making Sense or The Last Waltz. But as a documentary, it's great.

Quite a few of these acts are not only instantly forgettable but were actually instantly forgotten. (Au Pairs? 999? Invisible Sex? Athletico Spizz 80?) On the other hand, even those acts make it an interesting record of a certain period.

There are some good performances, some that are unforgettable but not exactly good, and a few that are excellent. A lot depends on if you are willing to see the performances as performance art rather than just music. Certainly seeing the Cramps' Lux Interior, covered in scratches, wearing black leggings that barely cover his genitals, and fellating a microphone while rubbing himself carries a kind of can't-look-away fascination. When Skafish does their "Sign of the Cross," complete with smoking censer, I always find myself wondering whether Jim Skafish's unbelievably huge nostrils will actually swallow the stage like a black hole. And how often do you get to see Klaus Nomi, a gay German falsetto dressed as a cross between a kabuki actor, a member of the commedia dell'arte, and a ballerina from Star Trek?

You also get to see that Devo was a truly great band -- their performance of "Uncontrollable Urge" reminds me why I loved them back in the day. You get to see XTC before they stopped performing live. You get to see the Go-Gos before Belinda Carlisle lost weight and Joan Jett before she lost weight. You get to see Echo and the Bunnymen, Wall of Voodoo, Orchestral Maneuvers in the Dark, Pere Ubu, and Magazine, all of which have their followings.

I love the film, and probably watched it a dozen times in the 1980s on Night Flight on USA network. It's been on HDNet twice, and both times I've missed the opening 40 minutes to an hour, so I haven't DVRed it, but when I do I'm definitely keeping it on DVD.

reply

Uneven or not, it is the most memorable concert film of all time! Some truly unforgettable moments from Gary Numan, the Cramps, and so many others that I can't mention them all. Plus all in HD! Wow! Not to mention the terrific closing performance of Roxanne by an incredibly young looking Sting and the Police. This is a must see movie for all fans of the genre.

reply

Best Concert(s) film ever

reply

For the type of music featured, the movie is pretty damned good. No filler BS. Just good edits and segues from the end of one band's song to another band, complete with band names and locations. Great performances. Hardly the best concert film but definitely one of my favorites. I collect concert films and live performances. Haven't seen this in 20 yrs. Brings back memories.

reply

The Last Waltz and Stop Making Sense are certainly better films. But, the distinction is that URGH features 35 bands, not one band. (OK, Stop Making Sense has Tom Tom Club)

Still, this documents a period of time that was quite fascinating. I remember watching it for the first time on Night Flight in 1982. I also remember that I played my copy of the tape constantly!



"It's so hard having a good time. Even smiling makes my face ache."

reply

Yes. amazing collection of great bands and unbelievable performances.

reply

I saw this in a theatre back in 1981. I was (purportedly) the films target audience--I was 18 and in college. Despite seeing it on a wide screen with the stereo sound blasting I was bored silly. The loud music kept me awake but I couldn't wait for this to end. The movies is incredibly disjointed--it goes from one band to the next with no rhyme or reason. The cinematography is terrible and some of the bands are (pretty obviously) hamming it up for the camera. It has some historical interest in seeing the Go-Gos and Joan Jett before they hit it big but little else. For a great concert film see "Gimme Shelter!". Even better see "The Decline of Western Civilization"--part 1 or 2. Those movies introduce the bands and give u a sense of who they are and what they're doing. Also it helpfully provides subtitles for most of the songs! "Urgh" is pretty bad. If it's such a great concert film why does nobody seem to know about it? It came out almost 30 YEARS ago!

reply

I remember some reviewer at the time describing this as the movie you'd send your mom or older relatives to see, to help them understand the kinds of music you were into. Sort of an introductory course or package tour of the "new music" scene.

reply

Yeah--I remember reading that too. It was called "a crash course in punk rock" or something like that. That was (partly) why I went--I wasn't into punk rock and was curious. BUT--as I said--this movie just bangs u over the head with it again and again and AGAIN without a letup. If anything this probably made parents more AGAINST their kids music. This got an R rating just for the way some of the acts dressed or behaved!

reply

[deleted]

Oh it def. WAS an example of the music of that time--I won't deny that. It just wasn't my type of music. Still it WAS fun seeing the Gogos before they cleaned up and Joan Jett before she hit it big.

reply

Seeing this movie in the theater with the audio pumping was almost as good as attending a concert by one of the 35 bands. OK, it wasn't as good as one band, but wherelse were you going to see such a diverse musical palette for such a low price?

After all, when was the last time you saw an obese (and I'm being NICE!) Belinda Carlisle? She does look a bit hefty in those pix. I can remember the DJ's were pretty cruel toward her and her penchant toward wanting extra cheese with her fries.

"It's so hard having a good time. Even smiling makes my face ache." - Dr. Frank N. Furter

reply

Wait a minute! Carlisle was hardly obese in that movie. Yeah she was overweight but obese? No. What surprised me most was how punk rock the Gogos looked and sounded before they were cleaned up.

reply

[deleted]