MovieChat Forums > Une vraie jeune fille (2000) Discussion > Was Jim masturbating?

Was Jim masturbating?

posted 17 years ago by dcampbell000
9 replies | jump to latest

Near the end of the film, it shows Alice and Jim on a beach in the middle of nowhere. But before that, he appears to be masturbating in the woods. Then she comes. Shortly thereafter, he seems to be masturbating on the beach as Alice has some kind of object rammed up her ass. Was he masturbating? If he was, he's one scrawny, horny bastard. He must've been masturbating later in the scene when she throws herself on top of him. The scene ends showing semen on his fingers. What a scrawny, horny bastard for having to masturbate right in front of a chubby young girl. Would you ever masturbate in front of someone like that?

[–] 17 years ago

[deleted]

[–] foof76 17 years ago

Exactly! So what? I totally agree! What is wrong with masturbation? I would think that was one of the more understandable actions in this film, as opposed to some of the other things being done/experimented. Out of all the other things shown in this film, how is THAT what surprises you? That a young man got aroused and took care of things?

"I'm a Gemini, and Geminis don't believe in astrology."

[–] tanner3212001 16 years ago

I have to agree with dcampbell on the fact that jim is a scrawny gross slug ! The punk rubbed me the wrong way from the beginning.

I've got a job, a secretary, a mother, two ex-wives and several bartenders that depend upon me

[–] Little_Tyke 8 years ago

I'd reckon just about everyone involved in the making of this movie was fapping at some point. There must have been a run on Kleenex or whatever the French had in 1975.

[–] tanner3212001 16 years ago

First scene looked like he was peeing.

I've got a job, a secretary, a mother, two ex-wives and several bartenders that depend upon me

[–] tanner3212001 16 years ago

Chubby ? She has a beautiful figure :) I guess you like stick figure beanpole girls with no figure :)

I've got a job, a secretary, a mother, two ex-wives and several bartenders that depend upon me

[–] dcampbell000 16 years ago

Chubby isn't a bad thing. It's a lot better than girls with no figures whatsoever. Most girls ought to have a little fat on them anyway. For good examples, watch Christina Ricci in Buffalo '66 or America Ferrera in The Sisterhood of the Traveling Pants. They look far more appetizing than any of those stick figure beanpole girls. To me, they're not at all chubbier than they probably should be. They look more like REAL women. And so did Alice. As for Jim, he's not much scrawnier than most men and he's no fat slob or moronic steroid-enhanced jock either. Therefore, Jim is more like a REAL man. Slender or perhaps even a little scrawny.

[–] Little_Tyke 8 years ago

Watch Christina Ricci in Black Snake Moan!

[–] Overblownego 12 years ago

These scenes can be kind of confusing. She goes from sunbathing in her yard, to anally experimenting with a large glass wine bottle shaped container of tanning oil. She then walks to the sawmill, her biking priveleges having been revoked in a prior scene and laments her tardiness as Jim is finishing his urination (possibly she regrets this because she wanted a peek). Apparently the sawmill is near the beach, which makes sense as she's walked to both locations at different times, she lays down and puts on a display for him, they then kind of mutually masturbate I think, either that or she just awkwardly lays on top of him while he does and the hops off while he finishes. She seems to be mindful of pregnancy later on, so it's likely that a wank session was what she was going for in the first place. Insulting Jim because he obliged seems a bit off, although I can't disagree it's not morally sound to be doing that in front of a "very young girl" in just about any culture.

As far as sexual practices goes mutual masturbation seems to be about as benign and hum drum as you can get. Growing up in the American public school system it was actually somewhat recommended as an alternative to any actual swapping of fluids. So I may be biased in my thinking here.