Because it's not. One of Scream 2's rules was "more blood, more gore" but the goriest bit was the scene with the police officer getting impaled. Cotton's death has a lot of blood, Steven spits up blood, and Tyson and Jennifer's deaths had a fair amount of blood.
You were able to list 4 deaths with blood, but EVERY death in 2 had some. There was more blood on Randy's body than all of the deaths in Scream 3 combined, and he wasn't even killed onscreen. There was also a general brutality to the kills, as opposed to stabbing everyone once and running away.
And I'm sorry, but nothing in Scream 2 was as bloody as the opening scene in Scream.
Maybe not, but the prevailing feel of Scream 2 was, overall, more violent/unsettling than the first one. This third is easier on the eyes though, because it's more conservative with the blood. I like the first movie a lot, cause it sets up the story. But, I could have done without the graphic image of Drew Barrymore's death in the opening scene and I could have done without the over-the-top craziness of the killers near the end---stabbing each-other FOR FUN?!
Movies like Scream can be made without that excess, just take Hitchcock's PSYCHO as an example. But, those scenes aside, it's a great movie-mystery, and for that, a favorite, same with Scream 3. Scream 2 though, it was just too eerie for me. I didn't care nearly as much for it. In fact, I was rather disappointed by it, because it took a definite more somber tone that I did not appreciate.
My least favorite thing about Scream 3 though, was the mother/ghostly scenes---because that's much more terrifying than a masked killer that can at least be caught!
Please excuse typos/funny wording; I use speech-recognition that doesn't always recognize! reply share
Honestly, I suspect more people just look to hate Scream 3 than would care to admit. There are legitimate gripes to the movie, but to continually harp on aspects that don't actually exist in the movie...
What about Tom's death? I didn't see anything like that in the other movies. Of course they didn't prolong his suffering like Green Mile, but that's quite violent.