Regardless Of What Else You Think Of This Movie...

I'm being calm and collected here

But still saying childish things. And no, I'm not being sensitive because I think it's strange to call someone's reasons for not loving a scene sh!t. You posted a thread sharing your opinion on that scene, and I replied thinking I could give my honest opinion. I didn't expect you to agree with me, but why would I expect anyone, especially a familiar poster, to call it sh!t?

what I actually said was that anyone who didn't get that the movie was clearly telling you that Verbal was Soze was an idiot

That's not exactly what you said, you just said how stupid some people can be. Besides, the person you replied to didn't claim that the movie wasn't telling that. Either way, it was a childish thing to say, even though I agree that the movie says Verbal is Soze.

When you weigh that against the positives of the scene, the cons outweigh the pros?

And what are the positives of the scene? I can only think of the flashbacks and a little chasing. You say you love the scene because it gives the feeling that she's actually back there again. Well, that's the problem for me, there's no way she could be back there unless she was in Woodsboro. The moment they showed the house, my first thought was that it was unrealistic they would rebuild it in such detail inside a studio. How am I supposed to shake off that thought when they keep showing impossible detail after impossible detail? How can I get emotional if they keep reminding me of how absurd it is? It's just like that dumb voice changer. Now, it may not be as bad as that, but it does stop me from "loving" that scene. And like I said, it's not just one thing I dislike about that whole scene. Now again, I don't expect you to agree with me. It's all just subjective opinion. You love that scene, good for you.

reply share

add reply

formatting help