A disgrace!!

I agree, it was far below my expectations. This movie was supposed to be the French answer to Hollywood...

The effects were not impressive (I was really hoping to see some action when they kicked the Romans out, but they just fly up).
Extremely dumb was the scene where Obelix explicitly needs a codeword to help Asterix and Caesar even helps him??

One little joke could have been good, when Caesars refers to his son Brutus. That could have been a cute 'inside' joke for some adults, but they put it in in a very artificial way, and when a joke is not particularly fantastic, you shouldn't stretch it out like that.

Well you don't seem to be aware of the difference between literature and film.
Thats why you alway refer to the comics. Comic is comics and film is film . You are comparing apple to oranges and therefore you are wrong.

I think that if this movie has any major flaws, it is probably that it attempts to press to many of the comics into it. I count Asterix the Gaul, Asterix and the Soothsayer, Asterix the Legionary, and I probably missed a few references. The point is, with those comics and the new material, everything seems a bit rushed and a little disjointed, especially during the first half. I would rather that they had left something out and explored the rest more. Overall I liked the movie, but yes, it does have its errors. I would not call it a disgrace, far from it. I have no doubts that the moviemakers are huge fans of Asterix, but as said, I would have preferred the adaption of one comic, as opposed to several of them in one movie.



At the top of the mountain, we are all Snow Leopards. -Dr. Hunter S. Thompson

it's quite fun.

I disagree.. Of all the three liveaction-movies this one is by far the best. It gives the animated features and the comics a run for their money and THEN some..

"I rather have a bottle in front of me than have to have a frontal lobotomy"