The case for Mrs. Tingle


I think I am one of the only people to think that those kids probably should have gone to jail for all of the things they did to Mrs. Tingle. Though she let her anger get to her in the end and there was the incident with the crossbow, she technically didn't do anything wrong. She was harsh and a bit unfair, yes, but so are many teachers.
Miss Watson could have still gone to any school in the world she wanted to and and I'm sure that there would have been many scholarships offered to her. She wasn't interested in cheating before she had her teacher tied up, but she was pretty much fine with changing her grade later and getting her coveted position as Valedictorian (which should have been stripped away for academic dishonesty). If we could all have a day with our teacher's gradebooks, we'd all be valedictorians.
I digress. The point here is, Miss Watson should have been prosecuted, along with her fellow criminals, for the things they did. I don't think she should have been given a reward for being a criminal who escaped prosecution. Mrs. Tingle probably would have lost her job anyway for the incident with the crossbow, but otherwise, she's pretty much innocent of any actual crime, while Miss Watson and her friends are guilty of kidnapping, breaking and entering and any number of other crimes.

~Me Aequabo Exelso~

reply

I completely agree.

I had my share of mean/unfair/sadistic teachers all through grade school, high school and college and, trust me, there were several who I would have to liked to tie to a bed and torture (in theory anyway).

However, there is a HUGE difference between fantasizing about committing that type of act and, actually DOING it!

The 3 kids were simply not sympathetic, IMO and, I found myself siding more and more with Mrs. Tingle despite her cruelty and deceitfulness.

reply

Further, Leigh Ann handed in a "C" project at best. I addressed this in another post, but her history project was rife with inaccuracies. As an arts-and-crafts project, it looked great, but as a history report, not so much. 17th-Century Puritan girls did not keep journals (Paper was a luxury item in those days - especially in the colonies). There were no burnings at the stake during the Salem Witch Trials. As much as I loathed the character of Trudy Tucker, her Bastille looked like a far better (and more accurate) representation.

reply

Surely it was to write the pretend journal of a 17th century Puritan girl.

reply

Surely it was to write the pretend journal of a 17th century Puritan girl.

reply

I agree 100%, EXCEPT I actually don't think the crossbow incident was THAT bad. If you take the circumstances into account, she'd been held hostage in her own home, "tortured"(a good laywer could make the case of course) for days, and in this stressed out, victimized state she goes a little over board with the crossbow, ATTEMPTING to shoot not a student, but her assailant. Any jury would be sympathetic to that, any school board SHOULD. The teacher's union should have had her back on this. She shouldn't have been fired and I doubt she would have been found guilty of any crime in a criminal court either.

This movie is complete hogwash. Are we supposed to root for these students? Just cuz Tingle is a despicable person and clearly a villain, doesn't mean these students are automatically protagonists. They were in the wrong BIG time themselves.

reply

I'm in Total agreement.

~Me Aequabo Exelso~

reply

agree

"I need more sex, OK? Before I die I wanna taste everyone in the world."
-Angelina HOlie

reply

It's just one of the many ironies of this movie which is the theme.

reply

I have had tough teachers who demanded more of me when I was in school. At times life is not fair. But having said that, it is not up to the teacher to be unfair and go out of her way simply because she does not like the kid. That crosses the boundaries. I would have filed a grievance or a complaint and told the everybody form the school board, the principal and even the media what she said. I would have made the b!tches life uncomfortable. Tingles' jealousy was stupid and for a person int hat position to do so was rotten and evil. That is not their job to be that way. From what I saw she got what she deserved.

reply

There is a vast difference between teachers (and for that matter bosses) that are tough in the challenging but wanting you to succeed ways, and those that are ruthless, cruel, and hurtful to their pupils and colleagues. Mrs. Tingle is one such example of the latter. Yes, she deserved what she got ultimately. Though I would not have actually done anything close to what the students did by physically assaulting and torturing her, I would complain to the administration for sure and possibly make a case with the school board. Mrs. Tingle and real life examples of her have probably had numerous complaints about them over the years, and probably even been documented at least once. I know they think they can win by getting people on their side and even trying to make a case in court if need be. But if the number of run-ins with other keeps growing, something has to be done. It usually starts with re-assignment, and when that fails it leads to suspension pending termination. If the teacher is tenured, they may be able to be relegated into another position and be "waited out" until retirement. Not always the case, but I've seen it happen.

I have had a few bosses that are difficult, and some that have not liked me simply because I am different and think outside the box. I have had good and halfway decent bosses on the flip side. As far as teachers, I have had many good and great ones, a few mediocre ones, some bad ones, and one really horrible mean one. In fact, she reminds me of Mrs. Tingle though knocked down a few pegs about it and always found someone to scapegoat that she did not like for whaever reason. She ended up moving into a non-teaching position in the school district a few later, followed by being promoted more than once and then retiring only to teach at a university for a few years before finally retiring for good. In my opinion, she retired a long time ago. A perfect example of how those who can do, and those who can't teach.

In order to stay relevant here, I also make the case of a few bosses my mother had in the big business industry, including one really horrible (dare I say sociopathic) one. He did not like women for one thing, and he resented the fact that she worked hard and was in such a high position. He was determined he was going to do whatever it took to make her life miserable and looked for reasons to get rid of her. I thought one year with a really horrible teacher or a year or two with a bad boss was awful. She had this guy for a boss for eight years! Yes, eight of her seventeen years with the company! She was miserable, and ended up retiring early because she could not take it anymore. He moved into a management position in another area of the company, and then eventually retired and went to teach at a university full-time and several colleges part-time.

My point is that sooner or later, what goes around comes around!

reply

Despite the fact that Mrs. Tingle was certainly a grouch, she DID catch the students cheating. They were the ones who broke into her home and threatened her with a crossbow, and held her hostage for several days. Mrs. Tingle would have been well within her rights to press charges, so the ending is complete bull.

Also, whatever writer came up with her brilliant History project did a crap job. She made a craft, not a history project.

It's also annoying that the school jerk-off is the love interest in this. Luke was lazy, had a huge annoying attitude, and led Jo on.

In any case, I was completely on the side of Mrs. Tingle and a realistic ending would have been if she pressed charges. The cut away to graduation is such a cop out quick way to 'solve' the impossible problem that the writer painted into a corner with no way out.

You're wondering what is a place like me doing in a girl like this.

reply

Life.is indeed unfair. That is not an excuse for following its example.

reply

I honestly didn't feel that bad for the students. I was sort of on Mrs.Tingle's side the entire time despite her harsh nature.

I'm feeling rough, I'm feeling raw, I'm in the prime of my life.

reply

Then I guess you all think that Nurse Ratched from One Flew Over the Cuckoo's Nest never did anything wrong either because she "technically" didn't do anything illegal.

reply

My thoughts exactly.

reply

There's a pretty drastic difference between punishing students who were cheating and being a controlling wench and abusing patients in a mental hospital.

You're wondering what is a place like me doing in a girl like this.

reply

This is a morally bankrupt movie for morally bankrupt people made by a morally bankrupt society. An atrocity and everyone involved should be ashamed of themselves.

reply