"Opinions are not right or wrong as long as they are based on something the person believes."
And based on what ?? Whatever you want whenever you want it to. Go ahead.
" Your opinion is no more right than mine."
Only in the idea of intent. Every argument you have given me holds no water and you cannot back it with anything the show was trying to do in terms of character.
"I was only trying to show you WHY I believe as I do about this particular series."
And you did. What's your problem ?
"Everything I said about the series actually happened in canon, however; most of what you are postulating is supposition based on what you thought was going to happen - it never appears in the series."
So THAT'S your argument ?? That everything that happened in the series happened. And was motivated by what ?? These weren't random events. They all happened for a reason and were building up to something. Surely you can see that. The series had a definite direction for ALL the characters,including Chris and Mary. You just can't or, more importantly, WON"T see it.
" So, you can have any opinion you want about what would have happened if the series had continued, that just doesn't make it so. "
By the same token, it doesn't make it NOT so,either. And the direction and events of the show bear me out, not your silly theory. Besides, you said that you, as a person, didn't want them to get together so you fabricated your opinions based on what YOU think should happen,even interjecting your judgment for Mary's in terms of caring for her son and/or leaving the paper. None of what you think bears out in the scheme of things as portrayed on the show. NONE of it.
"Go ahead and call me wrong,"
I have and do so again.
Case in point: Your charge Chris acted like a brother in WAGON TRAIN.
GERALD: I don't mean to pry, Mr Larrabee,but I notice you and she have something of a friendship.
CHRIS: You could say that.
GERALD: Anything else to it?
CHRIS: What are you asking?
GERALD: Forgive me,that was unfair.My competitive nature sometimes overwhelms my manners. Then again, a man would have to be blind not to notice HER charms.
CHRIS: Well,I ain't blind.
And this dialog was going while Mary was galloping in the background.
I don't think that was "brotherly",xeno, do you ??
"deny that anyone outside of yourself is a "true fan"
Never made that claim and never will. But you should watch the episodes more closely before you try and debate.
"enjoy yourself."
I do everytime I watch an episode. I re watched OBSESSION just to remind myself how much you still DON"T get it.
"Your the one that said I should visit a website - I was just pointing out that I do visit them and I'm on several groups dedicated to the series,"
Good for you.
" where btw, there are many other fans that don't see these two as a couple."
So what ?!? It was the INTENT of the series and it was written with that in mind.
"But that doesn't matter - "
Only that they, like you, won't see it.
"my whole point was that you cannot allow other fans to have their own opinions without castigating them for it and there are many fans that don't agree with you."
Look,xeno, stop playing victim, will you. Have any opinion you want. How many times do I have to say it ?? But what we have been talking about is as about as plain as it gets. You haven't presented ANY argument to the contrary based on events that occurred during the show's run. I nixed every one. Every nuance between Chris and Mary was so indicative of a future together it practically comes out and bites you.If the character of Mary somehow annoys you and you can't see her with Chris,that really is YOUR problem. But,to most of us,it was very obvious from the beginning. And, if by some miracle, there was ever a reunion movie of some kind with all the TV cast, you would see that subject,along with other loose ends,resolved to the original concept of the show. In case you don't know what THAT is, it was "Seven men,one destiny" and that destiny was the salvation and redemption of all seven of our damaged heroes. That was the concept of the 1960 film and, in a more leisurely fashion over proposed numerous seasons,the idea of the TV show. Being part of the Magnificent Seven had it's rewards for ALL of them. We just didn't get a chance to see them all. But they were getting around to all of them.Josiah with his sister, Nathan with his father,Ezra with his mother,and considering what he lost,Chris was going to find what he lost as well. THAT, my dear xeno,was Mary and Billy and regaining a family.
Do you get it now ???
" I guess it was foolish of me to engage you in a dialog in an effort to point this out. That is my ONLY mistake.'
And now you know better and,hopefully, you got a better idea of what John Watson,Pen Densham,and Richard Barton Lewis were trying to do.
"Every Troll Matters When Message Board
Domination Is Your Goal."
reply
share