Cursing?


I don't understand why they felt the need to add profanity to a family/children's film. I have a daycare and had been looking for a new film that had a great message. This was on many top lists for family entertainment. So, much to my disappointment, the characters used language I didn't want repeated by a group of 2 year olds. The scene with Hogarth praying really was sad. Cheap jokes at God's expense. The lead evil character says "screw" our duty. I wanna live?? Really??? Kids repeat what they hear. Try explaining to parents why little Suzie came home saying screw my duty. I just don't understand the choice to incorporate something that adds nothing to the film but rather will prevent some from sharing an overall good story with their kids.

reply

Okay, first of all, "overall good movie" is cursing this movie itself to my ears and heart. Second, don't be such a prude. If you don't like a beautiful movie with a few comparatively mild expletives to what 80 percent of kids hear at home, than just choose a different movie. How To Train Your Dragon, The Lion King, Aladdin, Spirited Away, so many wonderful choices with no curse words. I saw Simba's father die when I was 4 and a half and I thought he was sleeping, so the chances of a four or five interspersed profane words shouldn't have lasting damage on a child, when pretty brief and the main focus will be Hogarth and the Giant. Also, thirdly I suppose, why are you such a goody-goody? The Simpsons, Boondocks, South Park... Family Guy (the corruption!) , I was watching those shows when I was 9. Except Boondocks, I was like fourteen or fifteen then. My dear, Bebe, if you must be told what has been clearly known for years if you'd bother to google or pay attention, is that the creators don't talk down to kids.

Hogarth disobeys his mom, lies, gets chloroformed, is exposed to DEAR GOD, cursing! He's a smart kid who learns fast and adapts faster, like his great pal the Giant... well, mostly. He seemed a little hard to get over some of his later lessons. :( You can take this great movie for what it is or don't take it at all. I'm not putting up with blacklisting of this destructively underrated treasure. Go expose your little twerps to Veggie Tales and Barney, I'm sure they'll thank you when they turn out to be homely, stick-in-the-muds like a certain fine educator who bore them to blandness. Try watching effing Pocahontas 12 billion times and see if your imagination doesn't cry out in shame and pain. n

reply

Whatever, kids are gonna pick up bad language no matter what, might as well be from a comparatively good and moralistic film like this. It's up to people themselves to raise the kids right and not have them substitute mentally astute wording for something as cheap and unimaginative as some stupid swear words.

As a parental figure in training, however, I'd be more interested in the decision to show TIG to two year olds. From my perspective it seems a bit too much of a mature and hyperkinetic film. This, I feel, may have more risky long-term effects, at least more than a word whose meaning they can hardly even comprehend.

reply

When I saw the heading for this post I was trying to think of any offensive language. It seems unlikely that this would send any kid down the path to perdition.

As for showing this to very young kids, I have to agree that the language is the least of your concerns. The video came out when my kids were 8 and 3 and we rented it to help pass a rainy Saturday. We didn't know anything about the story, saw a kid with a flying robot and took a chance which we've never regretted. It became a family favorite, purchased and watched repeatedly. We all still quote lines of dialog 14 years down the road.

Looking back, I would have been concerned about some of the situations but my 3-year-old son never had a problem and, in fact, he became the movie's biggest fan. Still, I'd suggest that any parent watch this first before showing it to very young kids. It's a great movie and perfectly suited for kids but there are some tense situations. You'll know your kid and, when they're ready, it will be fine.

reply

I'm not a prude white-37. As far as the Simpsons or anything else goes, never felt the need to watch it. The fact you called my kids twerps shows that maybe you or maybe your parents should have been a bit more selective on what you watched. It's a parents job to be a "prude". It's not a bad film. I agree it isn't the right material for a younger audience.

reply

I'm not a prude white-37. As far as the Simpsons or anything else goes, never felt the need to watch it. The fact you called my kids twerps shows that maybe you or maybe your parents should have been a bit more selective on what you watched. It's a parents job to be a "prude". It's not a bad film. I agree it isn't the right material for a younger audience.


NO U

reply

You people really need to read my OP. Never said the cursing was going to send these kids to prison. Just asked what was the point of putting it in.

reply

By the way, just because a child may it may not have heard these words and worse at home diesnt mean I have to contribute to it.

reply

It's a shame to drag out this non-debate but I'd hate for any parent to be put off by the original post. The film is rated PG for "mild language and action sequences" (or somesuch). Any parent or caregiver should either watch the film or look someplace like this before showing it to young kids. In our house we often said "grace before meals" when the kids were younger but it never occurred to me that Hogarth's scene was in any way disrespectful. We all thought it was really funny.

From the OP's comments I assume that (s)he is of a fairly conservative religious background. That's fine. But this film is a great family/kids' movie with a positive view of family, love and spirituality. It's funny, emotional and has a message about tolerating differences that would benefit all of us.

Plus, I doubt that, with a nuclear warhead coming down, anybody would say, "Oh, to heck with our country..."

reply

yeah, it's like a pitbull, it's a great family dog but it could be dangerous.

reply

[deleted]

OK, first, you must learn that your religion is your personal choice and to most people your God is not as valuable as He is to you. Personally, I thought the prayer was incredibly funny. Of course, I am not religious at all and I don't believe in any all powerful deity. However even most religious people that I know would just laugh at this scene. Needless to say, though, if you want, you can find something to feel offended about even in the most harmless movie out there.

Second, showing a movie that you haven't even checked out before to a group of two year old kids speaks volumes of your abilities as a parent. And it doesn't speak good of you at all. There is plenty of websites all over the Internet where you can find a detailed content advisory for almost every movie you can think about. Like this one:
http://www.kids-in-mind.com/i/irongiant99.htm
Honestly, if you did check the movie out prior to showing it to your kids you would know that it is in no way appropriate for a two year old. It has on screen killings, it has a strong anti-violence moral and it has way too many references that will go over any two year old's head.




---
Click here:
http://soundcloud.com/tigermaster/

reply

IMDb doesn't allow cursing either, so the OP and the website are definitely compatiable. I don't even see why they won't let kids see curse words, it's not like they haven't heard it before. Two-year-olds watch Barney, don't they?

reply

I think most kids can comprehend the idea of cursing and profanity if it's explained properly to them.

reply

It wasn't made for people who get off on quoting others for the sake of looking intelligent either, jimn.

reply

For the sake of looking intelligent, I wouldn't have used quotation. But anyway, If you don't like being quoted, you won't get quoted.

reply