I rated this a 9 out of 10 and I proudly own it on Blu-ray
I don't understand why so many people have such a problem with this movie. It's a brilliantly made movie. Tom and Meg prove once again that they have the greatest chemistry on screen... like Katharine Hepburn and Cary Grant, Hepburn and Tracy, Wayne and O'Hara or any other great couple you could name on film.
I don't think You've Got Mail is as great as Sleepless in Seattle, but I think it's up there or I wouldn't have bought it on Blu-ray. I'm very picky about the movies I get in Hi-Def.
I wish people wouldn't look back at these great old classics, picking them apart for every reason possible, not appreciating the humanity and character displayed in them. I mean, look at the regurgitated romances today. Ever since The Notebook, almost every leading man is interchangeable and kind of dull. Every leading lady is kind of the same, in the fact that they're an emotional mess.
But, I can distinguish Tom's great characters in each of his films. Joe Banks in Joe Vs The Volcano is not the same guy as Joe Fox in You've Got Mail and they are both definitely not the same as Sam Baldwin in Sleepless in Seattle. Can you distinguish Noah in The Notebook from every leading man in any Sparks movie since?