Bobbie's Flashback


Tonight is the first time I have seen the entire movie from the first scene to the last. Therefore, I had missed this scene before, but now it raised questions.
When Bobbie is recovering from the beating he got from the security guard while robbing the vending machines, there's a scene where he's looking in the mirror at his battered face and he kinda of drifts into a childhood flashback. In the flashback, he is in the middle of a domestic fight between his mother and a man that looks like he is supposed to a younger James Woods. After beating his mother, this man turns and picks up Bobbie and throws him against the wall. This flashback occurs after the scene where James Woods comes to their apartment and gives Bobbie some heroin to help him with the pain from the beating.

Then in another scene right afterwards, Mel picks up Bobbie on the street in his new Cadillac, and he starts asking him how old he is now.....

Was Mel his stepfather? Or mother's ex-boyfriend? It was never really brought out in the movie. The boy who is Bobbie's roommate, Danny, is Mel's nephew, as he states when Bobbie asks him why he doesn't recruit Danny instead of him to show the ropes.

Also after the diner scene when Bobbie and Rosie get so drunk that they have to be carried home and put to bed, Bobbie looks up at Mel and says "Goodnight Dad".

That line never had any implications other than Mel being a mentor/father figure to Bobbie, as he initiated him into a life of crime. But after seeing the earlier scene with the flashback, that line took on a whole different meaning.

I haven't read through every thread, so I don't know if anyone brought this up before, but since it was just on Sundance tonight, maybe someone will go on the boards and answer this question.


reply

[deleted]

I was wondering the same thing. I thought it was just to show he had a broken home until it shows James Woods' face near the end... in that instant, I think it was to show the only memory he had of his father, being abusive and yelling, and James Woods was there as a symbol of distrust but also as his new father figure.

But you could be right, maybe he was an ex-boyfriend of his mom or something. Because Mel and Bobbie seemed to know each other somewhat; maybe years later, they connected and that's about the time Bobbie and Danny became friends? Maybe the reason Mel stayed in the place for 2 days at the beginning of the film, taking care of Bobbie, was because he felt bad about their past relationship? I know there is a "you're a doctor?" line delivered, but Bobbie was so out of it, maybe he didn't recognize Mel; maybe it wasn't until he looked in the mirror later that he remembered Mel from his childhood?

I'm not really sure, it is kind of a weird scene in the context of the rest of the film now that you mention it. Surely some scenes were cut out that would explain it... since nothing else in the film is really left to make you guess...
-
Shuji Terayama forever.

reply

Did James Woods gain weight for that scene or was he wearing some sort of a fat suit?

reply