I know it's a tall order, since almost everyone is perfectly cast! Just curious to know who everyone's favourites are, really, male & female. Here are mine -
My favourite "semi-regular" is Lady Agatha, think she's wonderful, also rather fond of Sir Ralph, too!
It's hard to come up with a least favourite, and I know she's hardly in it anyway, but I didn't really like Barbara Windsor as Myrtle - normally I like Barbara, but think she was rather weak in YRML.
I know what you mean about the Pawn Broker, he's chilling, isn't he? Great actor though. Absolutely superb as a jobsworth authority figure in the Poirot "Murder in Mesopotamia", could hardly believe it was the same man!
Cept we never get to see the pawnbroker in a family situation, so we can't know for sure he is the same as Stokes - who certainly has his good side! I do think he's actually more venal than Stokes, not to downplay Stokes' numerous sins. Bloody brilliant actor, though!
True, we only see the threatening side of the pawnbroker, whereas because we see alot more of Stokes, we also see his vulnerable side and so we can understand him better.
My favourite character upstairs is Cissy, and not just beacuse I think she's gorgeous! I like here character as well because she's the only one of the Meldrums who does have her head stuck up her arse!
Downstairs my favourite is Henry. You can't help but like him cos you know he's had a pretty rubbish life being in the Orphanage and all. Also, he's very funny and I love it when he's cheeky.
My least favourite character upstairs is Poppy. She's such a little cat! She's so self centered and selfish and the way she torments James is really evil.
Downstairs I guess my least favourite character is Constable Wilson. There never was a more lazy, freeloading, snobbish copper!
Dear Buddha, please send me a pony and a plastic rocket.
Definitely agree about Poppy. She really exploits James - she gives him the come-on, then when he thinks he's safe, she comes over all "What do you think you're doing?" and poor James doesn't know whether he'll be up before Lord Meldrum in the morning being given his notice.
She really, really uses him, I think. Especially at the end when she tells him she is going to marry Jerry, but - to James' credit - his simple "I hope you'll be very happy, Miss" upsets her more than it does him. I think she realises then that it's the end of being able to tease him and flirt and she can't have her fun any more, and - probably - she finds Jerry too stupid to want to be with forever.
So actually, I'm glad she got that ending.
"If we go on like this, you're going to turn into an Alsatian again."
How you could not like a copper that knows the difference between a Chateau Margaux and a Lafitte? Although I do agree about the cook, but she is very similar to the witch we had for a cook at boarding school back in the '50's. The casting of her and the acting is spot on. I truly empathized with Mabel's comment about her imagining her face on the carpet when she beats it.
upstairs: Lady Lavender (everthing about her is comic genious - her lines and how she dances about (especially when she practising throwing food at mrs lipton he he) downstairs: Mabel (one liners - when mrs Lipton tells her to go and beat the carpet and when Poppy comes downstairs for the first time and her comment when she leaves - i coudln't believe it), Ivy (she's so naive) and Henry (posh accent = v. funny)
Characters who could be a bit more nice to others
upstairs: Miss Poppy downstairs: Constable Wilson Mrs Lipton (she is sooooooooo mean to Mabel (referring to the endless food incidents) - I guess at least in the end Mabel got to eat once Mrs Lipton left and Mabel ruled the kitchen (although Mabel couldn't cook).
Hey, retrogal83, our lists are almost identical! Actually, James is also a downstairs fave of mine (I like the downstairs people a lot more than the upstairs ones). I have a teensy crush on James myself , but Ivy remains my fave because she can be so sweet and funny... (I'm a big fan of the "James and Ivy were meant to be together"-theory!)
By the way, I actually named my hamster Ivy, after Ivy from You Rang m'Lord . I used to have a rat named Sybil (after Basil Fawlty's wife), but my rat didn't turn out to be a very nice rat...so I thought if I'd try naming my pet after someone sweet this time, the animal would turn out to be nice too...and it actually worked! (A complete coincidence, of course, but a funny one... )
Darling, We're the Young Ones Hammersmith Hardwoman #11
The downstairs guys are just wonderful; one is able to be more empathetic with them. Their lives, loves and humanity are far more accessible because we - for the most part - aren't aristocracy or peers. Well I am not, for one!
Also, who wouldn't fancy James? Jeff Holland looks absolutely great, even today ;-)
I adore rodents too; I had a rat (bizarrely called Molly) and she was the sweetest thing ever. Who said rats weren't cuddly? Basil Fawlty actually :-s
***Do you like Liver and Bacon? Come and see my collection on the Isle of Man***
Heh, I always identify with upstairs more - not that I don't love the staff, I truly do, especially Mabel, Henry and Stokes!
And just to put myself completely outside the pale, I just don't find James/Jeff remotely attractive either *hides from the legions of Twelvetrees fangirls*.
But we all have love for this truly great show in common, anyway, lol!
Forgot to put my least faves. I don't like James, Mrs Lipton or Constable Wilson out of the downstairs lot and the only one I dislike from upstairs is Poppy.
Oh, this is going to be hard, picking favourites. I suppose for favourites it would be Mabel, Teddy and Rose (I love any scene with Teddy and Rose in).
I agree with PoloPonies about Myrtle - it's not that I don't like her, it's that she didn't have much of a part. You were never sure whether she was an old flame of Alf's or something more (I'm inclined to think they did have an affair, but maybe I'm wrong). She was just brought in as a means to break off the relationship with Mrs. Lipton.
But the ones I don't like are Poppy (she's so spoilt and spiteful, and I can't work out how it happened because Lord Meldrum isn't a very interactive father - he sort of sits back and looks on but does nothing), and also Lady Agatha. The reason I say her is because of the final episode. After all the years George has been having an affair with her, when he loses his money and is prepared to cast away all his social comforts to be with her (to be thrown out of his club and to know they'd never be able to go out and about respectably), she rejects him and says she wants to be with Ralph but you know she's only changed her mind about George because he's impoverished.
And I bet she then went off to find yet another man to have an affair with.
"If we go on like this, you're going to turn into an Alsatian again."
Yes - when Lord Meldrum started to cry when Lady Agatha left him, it was a real moment of tenderness. I felt so sorry for him - for all his faults, he really did love her.
Upstairs - Cissy (Just such a strong character, the first lesbian in a mainstream sitcom at the time I believe, Catherine plays her beautifully she is just so layered and multi dimensional)
Downstairs - Had to really think about this but it just has to be Mabel I mean where would the kitchen jokes be without Mabels "That'll be nice" the kitchen scenes without Mabel present were duller than the dishwater she constantly had her hands in (fave Mabel scene is when she begs James to give her her wages in advance so she wasn't evicted, she suddenly become more than just one liner cracking Mabel it really broke your heart)
Last faves
Upstairs - Poppy (I found this hard to do as I love her as a character and actress + think the show would be VERY dull without her bitchiness but just as a character she is so repulsive and the way she treats Ivy is pure nastiness at its height i.e the scene where she pours the red wine over her ballgown, again I love Poppy as a character for entertainment value but as a character in her own right she is just pure spoilt nastiness
Downstairs - Mrs Lipton (I just find everything about her character irritating and bullyish from the way she treats Mabel and Henry to her high and mighty attitude over "her" kitchen to the way she blindlessly adores freeloading Constable Wilson. Again I dont think the show woul dbe the same without her but Blanche Lipton just bugs the hell out of me as does her accent.
They think we're the demons now - Prue Halliwell ~ All Hell Breaks Loose ~ Charmed
Favourite upstairs would be Teddy, Cissy, Lavender and the parrot. parrot; "come in" Lavender: "shut up, come in" Parrot:" shut up come in". It broke me up every time I heard it. Least favourite of course is that witch "Miss Poppy".
I can't say that i disliked any of the down stairs staff, except perhaps the character of Mrs. Lipton, but she gets her comeuppance more than once and thus the character is very satisfying. Lavender hurling six plates of tapioca pudding at her was sweet.
Mabel doesn't get very much chance to shine, but there is one episode (i thought it was the last one of season 2), where Poppy comes down to the staff and starts nagging. After a few minutes, the only one who says anything is mabel: She a bitch, isn't she ? (or something like that). That had me rolling around with laughter.
@Tjizzle-Dizzle: I think the exact quote was "Cor, what a little bitch!". But you're right, that was one of the most brilliant Mabel-moments in the entire series. The beauty of that remark is that everybody is thinking it, but only Mabel is honest enough to actually say it!
Darling, We're the Young Ones Hammersmith Hardwoman #11