The Mutilator Vs Madman

For me I prefer The Mutilator...just.

They are both good horror/slasher flicks, The Mutilator is definitely more camp & fun, bringing more gore to the screen, even with one less kill (9)

Madman won points for it's cinematography, a better soundtrack (Fall Break is classic in The Mutilator though) and had a darker/creepier tone, with a jump scare.

Some of the characters in both films seemed very determined to find their friend/s who had been outside for some time. I guess this must be a convention in the horror/slasher genre.