MovieChat Forums > Madeline (1998) Discussion > Madeline or Matilda?

Madeline or Matilda?


Love to see them duke it out

reply

I actually had Madeline and Matilda taped one after the other on tape. I think Madeline was well done but I think Matilda wins by a whisker. I even called my pet pug dog Matilda. aka- Tilly.

reply

Madeline although I still realy like Matilda!

reply

dito wiht op

reply

Madeline takes the cake in my opinion! Though I loved Matilda too!

reply

Why are people always comparing the two movies, appart from title names, they're nothing alike.

It doesn't matter who we were, only who we are
The Answer Is Seven

reply

They are both Sony Pictures movies produced in the mid-1990s adapted from children's books with female protagonists.

Teach your friends the truth!
http://plum.cream.org/HP/poa.htm

reply

[deleted]

Matilda, though I really liked Madeline.





"Life after death is as improbable as sex after marriage"- Madeleine Kahn(CLUE, 1985)

reply

Matilda was a horrid child, wasn't she? I realise she had horrid parents but how can you compare the two?

Madeline!


What, just for once in your life can't you be serious?

reply

Madeline. Matilda is easily grown out of and now it's too childish. So I prefer Madelina more because I liked the main character more. She's cuter and smarter.

Sonic will be hearty forever.
"Mom, could I get one of these?" - Little Girl

reply

Matilda. I love both but Matilda wins this for me.

reply

Tough call. I Love both.
I'd have to say Madeline only just. I watched both one night after the other and that's my verdict.

reply

2 different kids. madeline fights with her fists and biting wit and matilda fights with intellect

reply

Matilda did more things to help her friends than Madeline did, so I'd say I like her a little better. Madeline still has some good moments though.

reply