MovieChat Forums > The Other Sister (1999) Discussion > What is Carla's disability?

What is Carla's disability?


Anybody know what the technical term is for her disability? Thanks.

reply

I think she also had a learning disability. In the Halloween Dance scene, when Danny gets upset because he failed his grades, and Carla follows him and tells him that in her special school she was told to start taking the easy courses first so that when she took the harder courses, they wouldn't be so hard for her. Just my thought...
Regardless, both actors portrayed their characters in a realistic & respectful manner.

reply

What she had has ABSOLUTELY nothing to do with Asperger's or Autism. (I know what I'm talking about. I have Aspergers)
Autists hate social interaction and have not this kind of facial expression ( some times not at all.specially not that kind of grinning found in this movie) Carla seems to have "normal" social skills or at least desire to have social contact so no Aspergers here. (many very high functioning autists and Asperger's people don't even want to fall in love or have relationships. in very great opposite to down syndrome or simply mentally challenged people)
She just have a low IQ that's all. Or she is "unblancedly" gifted but no social deficites here so no asperger's.

have a nice day.

reply

I also have Asperger's Syndrome, and I can attest that I very much wish to fall in love and have a relationship. I also have a great many facial expressions, including many variations of a smile. Not all Aspies 'hate' social interaction. We hate the pressure that is put on us when we are in situations requiring social interaction, and therefore tend to be very nervous about it, so we tend to avoid it. I desire to have social contact with others, but find it difficult for just those reasons. I know a good many Aspies who have jobs, own houses, and have families. Don't pigeon-hole us all with a few of the stereotypical symptoms. Asperger's Syndrome is called 'syndrome' for a reason. You don't have to have every single symptom that's possible to have the syndrome; you just have to have enough symptoms from certain categories of its symptoms to qualify.

I don't know what my IQ is now. In sixth grade, when I was looked at for Advanced Placement, I tested somewhere in the 140's. However, not all people with Asperger's Syndrome have an above average IQ. In fact, most actually have an average IQ. Also, most aren't gifted or savant. It's just that there is a higher ratio of gifted to ungifted people in the AS community versus the neurotypical world, paired with popular media's current obssession with Asperger's Syndrome and 'curing' autism that tries to frame us all as either some kind of scary, silent geniuses, or sad little children locked in our own minds. Those who have high IQs and are gifted are merely the most visible and publicised. There are some very low IQs in the world of AS, as well as some extremely high ones.

reply

[deleted]

Such an ass!

reply

Please people, "moron" and "idiot" used to be completely scientific terms so don't act like we're using a racial slur or something or something. Language is a living thing, always changing and evolving. If you think it's insulting to use "retard" in a derogatory sense, don't use it in that way, but don't try to force everybody to conform to your chosen, acceptable definition either.

reply

[deleted]

[deleted]

Actually retard is insulting. It was not used as a scientific term. You are right that moron and idiot were once used in a medical sense. The idea, however, is that people are people first. We shouldn't allow any disability that they have to define them. Terms like moron and idiot put certain images in a persons mind. Also, the only way I ever hear them being used now is to make fun of others. It's wrong to make fun of others.

reply

wow, I totally agree with you, and I as well have Aspergers and wish
to have a relationship/jobs/an apartment/etc.

Spaceballs: Funny, she doesn't look Druish.

reply

"Autists hate social interaction and have not this kind of facial expression ( some times not at all.specially not that kind of grinning found in this movie)"

they said people with AUTISM, not people with Aspergers, such as you.

reply

Asperger's Syndrome is on the autism spectrum. Do a bit of research. However, even what I guess you could call 'generic' autism differs between individuals with it; all people with autism don't sit alone rocking themselves and spinning things in an emotional vacuum. Disability to that degree was just latched onto as the stereotype, to the point where society-at-large ridicules the idea that anyone with autism can also posses the ability to function without being institutionalised or otherwise helped along.

reply

i was gonna say aspergers

reply

If you had a mother like Carla's, and an absent and nasty father like Daniel's, you be hard-pressed not to have a serious disability.

reply

>>If you had a mother like Carla's, and an absent and nasty father like Daniel's, you be hard-pressed not to have a serious disability<<

Then why did the two older sisters turn out country-club, tennis-playing, upper-crust OK? <g>

reply

She has mental retardation or more pc now is mental disabilities.

reply

Just a note people...

"Mentally retarded" is still an acceptable term.

"I'm not anti-American or anti-anything. I'm just anti-dumb***-mother****ers."

reply

<<Just a note people... "Mentally retarded" is still an acceptable term.>>

Perhaps where you're from, but certainly not where I'm from.

I'm in the UK and am a learning disability support worker. If I used that term I'd probably get fired. That's why some people on this thread are quite shocked by the use of such out-dated terminology.

reply

Actually it's being replaced with intellectual disability. This is even true about the term mental retardation. The only professional people, in general, who use the term mental retardation are those in the legal and insurance professions.

reply

that was meanie, i sorry

reply

Retardation.Finally a subject that Imdb posters know something about. LOL

reply

I just saw this movie again last night after not seeing it for a very long time & it was pretty obvious to me that her disability is mentally impaired or you could call it mentally challenged. Sounds a lot better than mentally retarded. I think Juliette and Giovanni both did very good in this movie.

reply

[deleted]

[deleted]

[deleted]

There are many ways to say intellectual disability but for this kind of borderline there are usually two reasons. That means that the most common effects for this kind of disability is caused either by a ex. high fever/illness while the child is young. During infancy and toddler years children are prone to brain damage due to an accident or an illness. But as this is not mentioned anywhere in the movie that means that most probably she was a "blue baby”.

Blue babies or as it can be they are called in many ways accordingly Birth Asphyxia, Hypoxic Ischemic Encephalopathy (HIE) etc is caused due to the lack of oxygen when a child is born. It can happen if birth during labour is delayed for too long or due to the child’s ability to breath afterwards. Blue babies are usually borderline in intelligence and are diagnosed with mild retardation. Essentially they have been brain damaged and that leads to people like dear Carla or worse.

By the way this is not internet knowledge I have 2 degrees and 2 more in progress to support it and a parent’s 3 more degrees and work with I.D. ;)

reply

I was thinking severe autism. Not Aspergers because that's high functioning autism. Carla's is lower scale autism, well actually somewhere in the middle, because low functioning autism, the person has trouble being able to speak and can't take care of themselves at all. And Carla's mom was having her go live on her own. You can never do that with lower functioning autism. Now Aspergers, since I have it, is the high end of the spectrum where half the time, you come across as more or less normal but then have these quirks where people will start asking "what's wrong with him?" It's the least understood for that reason. Since I, and other Aspergers I've met, are able to drive and live on their own. People's reception to that is usually, by my experience, an attitude where they have little or no interest in cutting you any slack about anything. If you can drive and live on your own without major problems (having trouble keeping up with paying your rent does not count), people are gonna think you've got just as much ability to function as anybody else. You might be able to see by the way I'm writing here that you may've not been able to tell I've got Aspergers if I hadn't mentioned it.

reply

Intellectual disability is very sporadic. It does not need to be caused by some type of ''syndrome''. There are lots of people who have an I.Q below 70 with no specific cause. So the Carla character just had an intellectual disability. But... people with I.D's don't act anything like this. Lewis's acting was deplorable, offensive and even laughable.

reply

I always wondered about this. Having worked in an Opportunity Development Center where we trained people with special needs to get out in the work force, I always wondered what the deal with Carla really was. It was never made clear so I am not sure if Lewis's acting was deplorable or not.
She did act like a few of the people I do know though.

reply