Ending


So, at the end of the film, is Henry running away from the plane or towards it? I know that there may be a certain degree of ambiguity left here on behalf of the director, but it would satisfy my own curiosity. Thanks.

reply

You're right that there is a small degree of ambiguity, of course, but I think we must conclude that he is running away from the plane. In the shot just before Henry starts running, he appears to be closer to the plane than the extended shot where he is running would allow were he heading toward the plane, yes? Also, I think it makes for a better ending if he is running away from "running away."

reply

I just looked at a copy of Hal Hartley's screenplay to the film. The final paragraph reads: "Henry is running, struggling towards us, forcing himself towards the plane, getting stronger and running faster with every step he takes. CUT TO BLACK."

So much for my theory, eh?







reply

i'll have to read the script and watch it again. it does make a lot more sense in context to have henry not run away from his problems (on the ground).

reply

I agree with you. I quoted the ending as it appears in the script for the record only. As a general rule, I don't let the artist's intention -- regardless of whether it is perceived or stated -- change my own interpretation of the work. But even if you take Hartley at his word, I think think there's still some wiggle room for differing viewpoints.

reply

definitely. leading up to the last scene with henry running, the camera and cuts were moving very quickly...the music and sound did a 180 when it showed henry running. to me, it doesn't make sense to have henry running towards the plane.

reply

That's a good point about the change in sound. I hadn't thought about that.

In terms of the story, I think the ending allows the audience to determine whether or not to allow any sense of dignity to Henry's character. In my opinion, he's earned at least this shred that we are willing to give to him.

reply

That would be a redoux of Hartley's ending to "Simple Men".

Simon would have made the decision that the things he 'has' accumulated, that are good (wife, son) are worth more than running away, and that he's willing to pay the price (jail time ?) to retain them...

reply

henry is running. that's all. he's on a runway and he's running.

does he have to be running toward or away from the plane? maybe he's running down the runway and starts flapping and takes off into the clouds.

yes, i also noticed the direction specified in the playscript. also therein lies the 'secrets' of a few other little mysteries of the film plot. i would recommend not reading it and experiencing the film for what it is, mystery intact. -- i think when a director directs from his own writing, he is not the same person. i suspect HH has reinterpreted his work for good reason.

reply

Where did you and rrebenstorf read the script? Because I looked on "Drew's Script-O-Rama," and I can't find it.


reply

So much for that theory. Still cool that the ending was left open to that interpretation. It was a 50-50 before reading the screenplay or Faye Grimm's release.

I Like Movies! They Are Cool! Yes, This Is My Message Signature -- No *beep*

reply

Dang -- I thought that the ending was ambiguous, but the HF was not running to the plane and that your theory was right.

reply

But first I have to say that I love this movie.


Okay, so Simon Grim helps out Henry Fool by supposively switching identities via Passport - so does this mean that Henry will take on Grim's persona completely? Will he show up in Stockholm to accept the Nobel Peace prize? If so, won't Grim's girlfriend notice? Concurrently, will Grim now go back to his garbage man life as before?



What have you done to his eyes, you maniacs!

reply

I don't think they're gonna give Simon the Novel "Peace" Prize for writting poetry near to pornography, but I think it will be funny if sometime such thing happen. And I don't think the're gonna change his lifes, but is an interesting and beautiful theory. I think Simon just feels like he has a debt with Henry and pay it this way, is his way of say sorry for break his promise seven years before.

reply

[deleted]

Obviously, Simon and Henry aren't going to "switch identities". First and foremost, because it is impossible to "switch identities". Seven years after his poem made it to the news, Simon had become a literary celebrity. He isn't quite the anonymous John Doe that he used to be, far from it. And, lest we forget, Henry has been arrested, and therefore had a mug shot taken, so it isn't likely that the police just "forgets" what the man they are after looks like.

What happens in the end, with the passports, isn't a "switch of identities", it is a way to get Henry out of the country. Simon will not go back to his garbage man life, and obviously he will receive the nobel prize, he'll just miss ceremony on account of his "missing" passport.

reply

I thought it was bizarre: Henry gives the ticket agent Simon's passport and tries to pass himself off as Simon -- but (1) he does not look like Simon, and (2) Simon stands RIGHT THERE next to him, and on top of everything else (3) the ticket agent is a big fan who knows who Simon is. But still she gives him the ticket and helps him to the plane. Huh?

reply

They show Simon handing his passport to a fellow in some back alley transaction and then it is returned to him with Henry's picture on it. I am assuming that the ticket clerk was familiar with his work and not his face.

reply

I never doubted Henry was running toward the plane, the plane he was late for, the plane that was being held up just for him -- not a situation where someone would leisurely stroll toward a plane that meant freedom, freedom from the hounds of hell at your heels. He does look back (if I remember right) with regret or maybe misgivings and I think that moment of repose mid-run as it were maybe has to do with why he speeds up afterwards, running like hell lest that pilot get tired of waiting. If he had decided to go back and face the music (it wasn't his music so why should he) why would he have been running with such urgency. It's not like the jail cell door was going to close if he didn't scurry. No, I think if he had decided to go back and face a jail sentence for something he didn't do he would have walked slowly, thoughtfully, and somberly. I can see no other reason to go back but to be with his family but he couldn't because he'd be in jail whereas if he leaves the scene of someone else's crime his family could join him. But my main point is one runs toward something desired, or away from something to be avoided at all costs, but one walks slowly toward one's doom.

reply

judging by the sequel, it would appear he was running toward the plane.

reply

i beg your pardon? sequel? there is a sequel to Henry Fool and I have somhow missed it?

reply


The sequel is Faye Grimm. Focus on Parker's character and her search in Europe for Henry.

reply

I happened to catch this movie on the big screen at the somewhat tender and impressionable age of 17. I loved it. Got reacquainted on video a few years later and still loved it. Finally watched the DVD just last night. I had almost forgot how much I loved it. Not quite my favorite movie of all time but certainly top 50. I came here specifically to see if there was discussion about the ending since I've gone back and forth on what exactly Henry is doing every time I watch it, which is one of the many things I love about this movie. Seems I'm not the only one. Well it comes as a bit of a shock and perhaps a let down that there was indeed a sequel released last year, 'Fay Grim', which settles definitively the direction Henry was running toward. I'll leave it to you to check the imdb page out and see for yourself, if you really want to know. I don't know if I'll bother with the sequel or not. Having just found out about it moments ago, I'm leaning towards 'not' but that may change. All I know is I wish Hartley had left well enough alone.

reply

[deleted]

Skip it. I too love this film (it's also in my top 50, #32 in fact, with only my top 41 so far getting 10/10 on IMDb), but I found that sequel unwatchable and turned it off after ten minutes or so.

--------
My top 250: http://www.flickchart.com/Charts.aspx?user=SlackerInc&perpage=250

reply

in the sequel, (fay grim) simon is serving a prison sentence for helping Henry flee the country. So I think it is fair to assume that Henry got on the plane. I know that many of you will consider this cheating and far less philosophical. Oh well.

reply

I watched Henry Fool for the first time last night, and w/o knowing the plot of Fay Grim I decided that Henry was indeed running toward the plane. The urgency of the flight attendends, and also playing back the running sequence, and checking the background -the plane in the background, etc.- led me to believe that he was running toward the plane.

reply

[deleted]

I interpreted it when I first saw it as him running towards the plane *shrugs*

But I think it was made a bigger distance because it parallels his walk towards Simon when they first meet, and how it keeps going as he comes up the street

I'm not putting this very well, haha

reply

This is a brilliant instance that I love to see in movies. An ending that has ambiguity and allows the viewer to draw their own conclusion. I tend to think of it as him running towards the plane. I felt his face showed enough pain that led me to believe he wants to stay and it breaks his heart to go but he must. He has to leave them or he'll eventually become a working stiff, wasting all his talent. He also may fear that his demons will come back to haunt him and he may not control his urge to sleep with young girls. He might even corrupt his son enough to scar his future and he doesn't want to do that. Again this is only my single solitary view, and it satisfies me :)

reply

uhhh.... dude, i think you missed the part where he was going to jail for murder... it wasn't so much that he'd become a working stiff etc etc.

but i agree with everything else you said.

reply

[deleted]