MovieChat Forums > Return to Me (2000) Discussion > Love the movie.......but?

Love the movie.......but?


It got me thinking, on the 3rd or 4th watching, when I was less emotional and more clinical, would it matter, if you loved someone and found out, part of her was donated, from your previous love?

It could go 3 ways.

1. No effect, either way.
2. It makes you feel shes even more special, and you love her more.

3. It creeps you out, and its simply too high a hurdle to get over. Maybe in a few years?

Personally, I believe, I'd fall into group 1. After mourning, when I felt ready to get out there, if I found someone really special, and feelings developed, that discovery would be a wow moment, not much more.

reply

I hope I would be in the first group.

We're gonna need a bigger boat.

reply

My guess is you have never lost anyone you were in love with, like a spouse or partner. After mourning, sure, you feel ready to 'get out there.' But to meet someone, develop feelings for them and then find out they have your former spouses eyes, or heart or lungs. You truly think this would have no effect on you? You think you would just say be able to say "Wow. That's cool" and then talk about where you will get dinner. God, I hope not. To meet a total stranger who is literally alive because a piece of someone you loved is in them must be overwhelming. To fall in love with someone and then find out this information? I can't imagine the emotions. I have watched this movie so many times and when he puts his ear to her chest to hear the heart beat - it gets me every time.

reply

You explained it beautifully. The fact is, can it be possile to have an extremely close relationship with someone and NOT think every time that she has your wife's heart? I don't think it's possible to have that relationship.

When Marty and Bob met and Marty said that the heart was always meant to be with him, it was such a beautiful thing to say but how do you not think about your first wife? If you're intimate with your second love, is it possible not to have your first wife in your mind?

I do not think a relationship like this is possible but it was very touching to see David listen to her heart when they were in Italy.

reply

I think that a relationship like this is possible as long as your second love realizes that they are the second one, and that you have loved before. It's because of Grace's character that the relationship is possible. She has always been accepting of the fact that Bob had been married before married her, and that she passed away tragically. She doesn't try to gloss over that part of his life, because she realizes that it's there, and it's a part of what made him the man that she's falling in love with.

My mother passed away when I was in my very early 20's. My father went through mourning, and after asking my brother and I if it was okay with us, he began dating again (our mother always knew she would go first, and always told me that she wanted my father to date again). He eventually fell in love again and got married. I didn't have a problem with that, and wouldn't have any problem with her if it weren't for the fact that my father has taken me aside in the past to ask me not to speak about my mother in front of his wife because it makes her feel uncomfortable. I respect his wishes because he is my father, but it hurts to hear that, because it is like she is trying to block out any kind of reminder of a woman that he was married to for more than 30 years and is the mother of his 2 children. If Grace were like that, then in no way could the relationship survive. But when you see them sitting on the couch before she finds the letter, he talks of Elizabeth and she encourages him to go on. With someone that understanding and that open, of course this relationship will be able to survive. Will they have their faults? Of course. But the happy moments will outweigh them.

"Oh my God! You put a living room where the crack den used to be!"

reply