A socialist cartoon?


I think that I'm being over-analytical, but I wondered whether the cartoon could be considered 'socialist'. For example:

i) The first song goes 'no one greater than all'. Then Arthur sings of how 'they'll each divide in equal shares our countryside'.

ii) Then at the round table, Arthur tells Ruber that they will divide land 'according to each person's need'.

iii) At the end of the movie, Arthur tells the congregation how the strength of a kingdom lies not in the king, but in the people. (although this argument by itself doesn't mean that Camelot is socialist)

iv) When we see Kayley singing in the first part of the movie, we don't see any peasants cultivating the land or tending to the livestock - it seems that only she and her mother are the ones running the farm. This seems slightly odd, considering that Sir Lionel was a knight, and therefore would ostensibly have fiefs. The only servants we see are in the house, and even then, they appear to be only domestic servants.

v) Ruber could be portrayed as the greedy, selfish capitalist - at the round table, he replies to Arthur's distribution of land: 'Then I need more than anyone..." His obsession with material wealth is shown in his own song. His accent (British) clearly makes him a foreigner - all the other characters in the film, save Devon, have American accents.

I know that it is over-analytical and WB probably never had any intention of portraying the kingdom as socialist - it is just a story on morals and justice, but I would like to hear some of your views.

reply

And this is a bad thing?

You just seemed to be lacking an opinion as to whether a pro-socialist movie would be a good thing, which is unusual.

"Life sucks, and then you die. And then it still sucks."

reply

[deleted]

Oh, I absolutely agree that there are very strong socialist principles presented in this film. i have to think a socialist or at least very left wing screenwriter snuck that stuff in, and as I am pretty left wing myself, I find it all kinds of awesome. :)

--------
See a list of my favourite films here: http://www.flickchart.com/slackerinc

reply