Cucumber sandwiches


in the interview scene, the sandwiches that Hanna makes don't look that great to by honest and i don't think I'd eat them.

http://img409.imageshack.us/my.php?image=dodgycucumbersandwichesvj5.png

would anybody eat them?

reply

[deleted]

sometimes the soggy texture of food really turns people off.
and the colour other times, regardless of the taste.

I like cucumbers.

please excuse me while I go make a soggy cucumber sandwich. LOL !!!



"google it if you dont think so ...."

reply

All about cucumber sandwiches...

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cucumber_sandwich


"When a good movie is successful, it is because of a misunderstanding."
--Godard

reply

That's brilliant! Someone actually took the time to create a Wikipedia entry for cucumber sandwiches!

Here's my rewrite of the artice; it's a little shorter...

Some bread + slices of cucumber inside = cucumber sandwich.

A little more succinct, I think! Personally I find them fairly bland. I like cucumber in salad, but on its own, they are just rather tasteless and tend to make an already bland sandwich into a bland, soggy sandwich!

I can't believe I'm discussing cucumber sandwiches on a film site!! :)

reply

it's really not so strange to be discussing cucumber sandwiches on a film site. Nothing is mentioned in the film (or any film really) without some purpose. The sandwiches are symbolic, they point out (as so many things in the movie do) the class distinction between Clay and Whale. Whether you, or anyone, like them or not don't mean a damn thing.

You--lighten up. You--big trouble. You--get in the car.

reply

I get what you mean, but I've personally never understood why cucumbers ARE a class thing. They aren't particularly expensive, or exotic! Caviar costs a fortune, so I can understand that being a "class food", likewise Champagne and salmon (although I must be terribly working class as I can't stand any of 'em!). Paying £100 for a piddling jar of caviar is definitely a sign of being loaded.. buying a cucumber for a quid in Sainsburys just doesn't have the same connotations for me! :)

reply

It's a class thing because cucumbers are not nutritive at all. So lower classes who only would have so much money to eat, would go for nutritive and "useful" food -> The one that allows to work in the mine, or the factory and do hard labour.

On the contrary, the upper class could eat all day whatever they wanted to - so they ate cucumber sandwiches at high tea so that their appetite wouldn't be spoiled for dinner.

*****
With the newspaper strike on, I wouldn't consider dying! /Bette Davis/

reply

Hadn't thought of it that way. I suppose it's a remnant of those times which has kind of stuck, and is still perceived as posh, despite the fact they are now cheap. They are made up of something like 95% water, or possibly slightly more, so they definitely wouldn't impact on an appetite! Personally it's one food item I can live without.. bloody slimy and tasteless I think! Mind you, at least they aren't brussel sprouts; whoever picked the first one of those and decided it made a good meal should have been battered to death with a cucumber!

reply

Don't forget the butter !



"I say, open this door at once!We're British!"

reply

Don't forget the butter !
I have to admit---buttered bread and cucuber slices sounds wonderful! And toasting the bread a little would remedy the sogginess. Perfect! I think I'll have one, yummy!!

Please excuse typos/funny wording; I use speech-recognition that doesn't always recognize!

reply

I have never heard of anyone toasting the bread ! I think ,in England at least, that it might be considered blasphemy. (But go on. Let me know how it turns out.)

"Life is uncertain, eat dessert first!" -HOMER J.SIMPSON

reply

would anybody eat them?

They're really quite popular. They're an afternoon tea or cocktail party staple. Have you ever tried one? Probably not. Why don't you try one before you make some insipid little remark about things you know nothing about simply in order that you can tell your schoolmates that you have something posted on IMDB?

reply

HAHAHAHAHAHA - bless!

J.

reply

a well-made cucumber sandwich is one of life's delight, but you have to search far to find them. The tea house at the Huntington Library in Pasadena, California does them up beautifully. Also ginger/carrot/cream-cheese sandwiches. But you have to like the whole idea of afternoon tea to go along with this.

You--lighten up. You--big trouble. You--get in the car.

reply

a well-made cucumber sandwich is one of life's delight, but you have to search far to find them. The tea house at the Huntington Library in Pasadena, California does them up beautifully


Golly - I haven't been there for tea since maybe 1997! Yes, they do make nice sandwiches. My favorite cucumber sandwich is on that fancy little square bread you can buy in the ritzy section of Gelson's and then spread it with a little bit of herbed Neufchatel cheese. I like to lightly salt the cucumber slices first and pat them dry first so they sandwiches don't get all soggy and I take most of the peel off because it's bitter. I leave little thin stripes of the peel on for appearances sake. Yummy yummy.


reply

every once in awhile one meets a soul-mate.

You--lighten up. You--big trouble. You--get in the car.

reply

Another Tea sandwich I used to love to make was when Brummel & Brown still made their several varieties of buttery Yogurt spreads in fruit flavors. Now they only have strawberry but they used to also make Apple-Cinnamon and Blueberry. They had the consistency and mouth feel of butter but were made with yogurt as well and of course, the fruit.

Here's a link to the Strawberry:
http://brummelandbrown.com/product2.aspx

Anyway - I liked to spread the apple-cinnamon flavor on pumpernickel bread, add sliced apples, some thinly shaved sharp chedder or a nice mild swiss like Jarlsberg or Emmenthaler. The combo of the crisp apple, the nutty cheese and the buttery apple spread was just high tea porn.

I suppose I could use the strawberry spread to make strawberry cucumber sandwiches, those can be nice.

reply

One of my favorite restaurants now serves water in pitchers with thin cucumber slices, instead of or in addition to lemon. Very nice.

Let's see how much further from the thread we can get.

You--lighten up. You--big trouble. You--get in the car.

reply

Actually, cucumbers are a very good source of Vitamin A, Pantothenic Acid, Magnesium, Phosphorus and Manganese, Vitamin C, Vitamin K and Potassium. And they're yummy. England'd classic Pimm's Cup wouldn't be the same without the cucumber garnish. And cucumber and yogurt cold soup in summer is delish. But you have to like cucumbers. (and obviously I do)

And then there's pickles . . . . .

reply

"with a little bit of herbed Neufchatel cheese."

Well that would certainly add to enjoyment. We used to make them back in art school days at Pratt in B'klyn just to show a little different slant to the out of towners who hadn't even gotten to yogurt yet.
Not a big deal couple times a month and definitely used for avoiding getting a monster craving later on at a party and looking like a little piggy. Knocks the edge off and can help soak up the beginning stages of upcoming wine drinking. Nothing makes for a headache the next day more than starting drinking on an empty tummy.
btw Baby foods & liquids great for dealing with a headache from drinking badly.

Really enjoyed this film back in the day. Manhattan crowds are the best to see any kind of 'new material' films. Not that there is much that qualifies as such these days.
I'd expected more out of Fraser in future days but can't fault him for going after the bucks over the art. Make the bucks so can make the occasional one for love of it where can pull out all the stops.

reply

In the summer of 1960, my niece (two years my junior) were staying at her maternal grandmother’s house one sunny afternoon. We were typical kids, more like brother and sister than uncle/niece. Being active kids, we worked up an appetite and asked Grandma for some lunch. To our surprise/amusement and disgust, Grandma served us cucumber sandwiches on white bread with the crust removed. We looked at them incredulously. Neither of us had ever seen such a thing and we could tell instantly that this was not a kid-friendly meal. When grandma wasn't looking, we threw our sandwiches into the corrugated metal garbage can. We had decided that hunger was better than those weird sandwiches.
To our embarrassment, Grandma later went to deposit some trash into the same bin and discovered our secret. We told her we weren’t really hungry after all and couldn't eat them. She was obviously disappointed in us and I believe she blamed me, as I was older, a boy and not a blood relation. The memory of this still comes with mixed feelings. I always felt somewhat guilty about this and yet how could any reasonably intelligent adult think this was what kids would want for lunch?

reply

I wasn't born till 1970...But when I was a kid if someone would fix me something to eat I would eat it...But hey my brother 1 year younger still to this day only eats like 8 things... Hes never going to try anything else...Just say'n grumpyoldguy1 you were just a kid...


http://youtu.be/ifJYxdV57go .
http://youtu.be/9WNPorqIyD8 .


reply