MovieChat Forums > Ever After (1998) Discussion > It's difficult to make this kind of movi...

It's difficult to make this kind of movie now


The Princess Bride killed it for movies of this type.

I found that this one wasn't sure what it wanted to be. A love story? A comedy? Some kind of satire? Very confusing.

reply

[deleted]

Tried to like it. Certainly liked Anjelica Huston, but somehow my attention kept wandering away from it.

Looks like it gets a 7 on IMDB. More than generous in my book. :)

reply

[deleted]

Ever seen The Princess Bride?

Switching too much between genres messes with the ability to appreciate it. Things start to not make sense.

reply

[deleted]

Are you saying that the Princess Bride was difficult to appreciate? I'm not sure what you mean.

reply

[deleted]

No, that The Princess Bride pretty much killed the category.

reply

But there really was no category for The Princess Bride to kill. That's why it bombed upon release as they didn't know how to market it. I would think that instead of killing the category it created it.

reply

They didn't know how to market it because Hollywood bean counters are generally pretty stupid about anything that's outside the box, that's not the nth sequel.

If we say it created the category, it also killed it at the same time.

The only movies that have done something more interesting with it since then are the Shrek series.

IMDB Ratings
The Princess Bride 8.1 (369,677 raters) Rank: #236
Shrek 7.8 (578,242 raters)
Ever After 7 (66,051 raters)

reply

[deleted]

It’s a specialty niche.

Ever After has a cult following among costume nerds. The designer did truly amazing work for this film. The vision was spectacular and the budget supported the vision.

http://www.frockflicks.com/ever-after-1998/

reply

I’m not a big fan of The Princess Bride. It’s not a film I have felt compelled to watch again and again.

Ever After is sweet and charming, has gorgeous costumes, and I have to watch it a couple times a year for the cast of top notch actors. Judy Parfitt, Timothy West, Toby Jones, Jeanne Moreau, Jeroen Krabbe, Lee Ingleby, Angelica Huston, and Drew Barrymore.

reply

Wow! Someone after my own heart. And I thought I was the *only* one cold on The Princess Bride and in preferring Ever After.

reply

What is wrong with calling it a cute for kids romance?

reply

I'm gonna be alone in this, but I actually prefer this to The Princess Bride. 🤐

Despite being a big fan of early Rob Reiner, Christopher Guest, Billy Crystal, Peter Cook, Mandy Patinkin and Wallace Shawn (not to mention Peter Falk and Fred Savage), I never got the love for The Princess Bride. Ordinarily a tongue-in-cheek fairytale/fantasy story would be right up-my-alley, particularly compared to a 'straighter' fairytale story. But what I love about Ever After, probably my all-time favourite take on Cinderella, is that it downplays Cindererlla's good-looks (ironically, seeing as Drew Barrymore is theoretically one of the prettiest actresses to play the character), and focuses instead on her intelligence and inner-beauty, whilst making at least one of the wicked step-sisters a more traditional beauty (and were it not for her haughty sneer, someone whose glamorous blonde looks would make a more likely candidate for Cinderella, physically-speaking, in contrast to Barrymore, who is made *down* to be a plainer and more unassuming brunette).

In that sense, The Princess Bride, in which the main couple are classically good-looking 'Aryan' blond(e)s (yes, Cary Elwes supposedly has some Jewish ancestry, but he looks almost as WASPy as Brad Pitt and Val Kilmer), whilst the villains are composed of a dark man of Greek heritage, another dark man of Jewish heritage (whose character has a physical deformity), and a Jewish midget (ironic, seeing that the film's writer, director, and the grandpa and grandson he's reading the story to, are all Jewish; then again, EVERY race and ethnicity SIMPS for the blonde, blue-eyed Aryans, DESPITE everything the latter did to the rest of us 'ethnics' and POC).

reply