MovieChat Forums > Brokedown Palace (1999) Discussion > FOR ALL THOSE WANTING THE TRUE STORY!!!!...

FOR ALL THOSE WANTING THE TRUE STORY!!!!!


I have seen several posts that mentioned that this was a true story and I haven't found where anyone has given a tangible answer. So, here it goes.(Mind you, I THINK this is MOST LIKELY what was the inspiration for this film as they say it is "loosely" based on true events.

I watched the documentary today about Krista Barnes and Jennifer Davis (both 19 years old I believe) who were jailed in Lima, Peru in 1996(Just three years before the release of this film) for trafficing cocaine.

Both girls became best friends while working as club promoters here in Hollywood. A Peruvian friend of Krista's came back into town after an extended absence and shortly there after invited both of the girls to live in his spacious ocean side home. Naturally, they accepted.

Some time later, three of his Peruvian friends came to visit and one morning the three friends (supposedly behind their friend's back) offered the girls an all expenses paid two-three week vacation in Peru + $5,000 each in exchange for bringing back "a very small quantity of cocaine" that would be hid in the lining of their suitcases and they would never even know it was there. After thinking it over for a couple of days the girls decided they could put $5,000 in the bank and split the other 5,000 to visit their families in the Mid-West and Michigan upon their arrival back in the States so, they accepted.

Once they arrived in Peru, they knew it was not going to be as rosey as the gentlemen had promised. They were greeted by two over-bearing men who immediately took their baggage to plant the drugs and put them up in a crappy hotel and demanded they not leave.

When the job was done the men took the girls clothes and packed their bags. When they returned them the girls immediately removed all the clothes to make sure there was no sign of the cocaine. To the naked eye, nothing was amiss.

When they arrived at the airport, there were custom agents and drug dogs everywhere to sniff out would-be smugglers. When the girls approached the ticket counter there was already a customs agent there. He asked the girls routine questions as they made their purchases. Sensing their story might not be entirely accurate (the customs agents at this particular airport are highly trained to spot smugglers) he took them into an interrogation room for further questiong where each girl denied having drugs. Using a tool to puncture the sides of the bag, they found the cocaine.

After nearly an hour of dismantling the bags all the cocaine had been removed. The "very small quantity" the girls were to bring back was actually upwards of around 20 pounds of cocaine! Said to be worth merely $5,000 in Peru, here in the U.S. where they were in route to, it would be worth well over a million.

They were immediately jailed and incarcerated for 18 months before they were formally charged. In March of 1998 they were sentenced to 6 years, one more than the minimum 5 years (in America they would have received a minimum 10 years).

Finally, after nearly three years of negotiations made by both their Peruvian attorney and a team of American law students, they were released for good behavior on March 23, 1999.

-----Although, not nearly as severe as the story in Brokedown Palace, I'm sure this was the inspiration for the film given how recent this had happened in comparison to the films release.>>>>>THIS DOCUMENTARY CAN BE SEEN "ON DEMAND" WITH TIME WARNER CABLE! It's under Entertainment>Natl Geographic>Hit Shows>*Locked Up: Peru* (Keep in mind todays date of 10/19/07 as it may have ended by the time you are reading this.)

I hope this helps!

reply

Great post. I myself was curious of the true story that was the inspiration for this film. Funny to see how different the film is. Thanks for posting.



"Hope is a good thing. Maybe the best of things. And no good thing ever dies."

-Andy Dufresne

reply

your right about that

reply

Check out the documentary Ganja Queen http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0923699/?ref_=fn_al_tt_1

True story of an Australian woman who got a 20 year sentence (with some officials calling for the death penalty) in Indonesia for smuggling marijuana. She was on a surf holiday and claims a huge bag of marijuana was slipped into her boogie board luggage while the bag was out of her possession at the airport.

Update - she's been released after NINE years in Indoneian prison. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Schapelle_Corby

🐾

reply

I was surprised to see that someone on here knew the real story behind the movie's plot. I wish that I could see the documentary since I only know the story secondhand. Jennifer was a senior my husband's freshman year of high school and in her yearbook photo she looks so pretty. We saw her sometime in late 2002 at a music store that she was working in near their home town(I had no idea who she was) and she looked so different (and not in a good way)that he almost didn't recognize her. It's horrible what she had to go through, though my husband thinks she should have had to suffer the consequences of her actions given the fact that she knowingly made a decision to break peruvian laws.

reply

I posted this on a similar thread a little ways down, but here is my same post again.

The producer of Brokedown Palace himself said he was inspired to make this film to represent NUMEROUS young women he came across in third-world prisons for falling victim to the charms of a male drug dealer. Here's the link:


http://www.foxmovies.com/brokedownpalace/brokestory/story.html

It just so happens that this particularly story the OP mentions here was very similar. Basically, the stories are almost ALWAYS the same (in fact, the women's own lawyer said to them "you can say you're not guilty; EVERYONE says that!")

reply

[deleted]

Wow, atleast I can stop crying now everytime I see that movie. That kind of pisses me off. They really made it seem like the entire movie was a true story. Thank god someone brought the "Real" story to light. I always wondered what happened to both girls. Thank you so much!

reply

ShayShay, you can keep crying. It is a true story....it's just not one specific true story. Plus, the film doesn't make it out to look as if it is a true story in the least. Everyone just assumes it is because the characters are so identifiable and relatable.

Well...my other God calls - The Honorable Sheriff of Nottingham

reply

That is an interesting story, but what makes you think it is related to Brokedown Palace? It is, after all, a not-uncommon scenario...

reply

[deleted]

I totally agree. That story is interesting but doesn't seem any more related to Brokedown Palace then any other story of naive tourists, drugs and prison in foreign countries. My poor roomate is desperate to find out if "Alice" ever got free? Should I tell her it wasn't really a true story???

reply

A lesson for all, stay in the freaking first world, people!! Stay in the US - if you want exotic, go to Hawaii; if you want foreign go to Australia and Western Europe. Just my two cents.

reply

I think the lesson is more along the lines of: don't be a drug mule, no matter how cute the guy is. Seriously, there's no reason to limit your self to so-called "safe" travel destinations if you keep your wits about you. You can get yourself into hot water just as easily in any of the places you mentioned if you don't use your head. Don't rob yourself of the wealth of experience out there because you're afraid you won't be able to resist the desire to do the wrong thing.

reply

The orignal post has nothing to do with Brokedown Palace... it was an episode from the series "Locked Up Abroad". Any one of the episodes could be loosely translated into being the inspiration of BP.

The truth of the matter is this happens all the time. The fact that Brokedown Palace is based on actual events does not mean it is an actual true story. It is a movie based on the occurrances of many girls across the world and how they are duped into becoming drug mules.

reply

Here is the story behind the movie. It's not based on any specific incident.

http://www.foxmovies.com/brokedownpalace/brokestory/story.html

Some people have weird fetishes. Which is fine. Then they take photos of them, which is not.

reply

[deleted]

[deleted]

Good story. Thanks. I've been to Thailand 8 times, all together. And after seeing this movie, I always keep a close eye on my luggage before leaving to the airport to come home. This movie might make some tourists not want to travel to certain countries. Lot's of good ganja in Cambodia, so I always make sure to get rid of it before returning to Thailand.

reply

I think this could be based on any woman that is locked in a 3rd world jail for smuggling.

For a truly heartbreaking documentary you should check out "Pack, Strap, Swallow". I caught it on the Sundance channel. It followed a bunch a different women (South African, German, Polish, Americans) in a South American jail who were caught with drugs. Really great film. Although I'd really like to know what happened to them.







If we don't believe in freedom of expression for people we despise, we don't believe in it at all.

reply

I heard it was based on Patricia Cahill's story.

Look it up on wikipedia. Patricia Cahill, drug smuggler.

reply