MovieChat Forums > From the Earth to the Moon (1998) Discussion > Why insert fictional characters into an ...

Why insert fictional characters into an already compelling story?



I liked the series, but i didn't love it. Part of what bugged me was the completely unnecessary fictional Emmett Seaborn character as well as the entire Apollo 13 episode about a fictional story involving fictional newscasters on a fictional network.

It's a great idea and makes perfect sense to have an episode of the miniseries be about the relationship between the press and NASA during the moon landings, but given the fact there were memorable newscasters like Walter Conkrite (who was REAL) who actually covered the story, why not tell the actual story with actors portraying the real people? In this instance, fabricating someone and then inserting them into history just doesn't make a whole lot of sense.





reply

It was not fiction, from what I've read this is when one of the networks was trying something new, like focusing more on the families and the emotional side of things. Emmett was old fashion and dealt with just the facts, and the younger kid reporter was something different back in those days. Kind of like today there's all these reality programs like TMZ, Entertainment Tonight, etc.

So it's based on true events. Maybe some one else can shed some more light on this episode.

"We pruned the hedges of many small villages" (the three amigos)

reply

frankd, I have to respectfully disagree with you.

Of course, I don't know your age, but I'm of an age closer to the producers of the series and the Emmett Seaborn character is one of the most brilliant techniques of the entire work. There's two reasons for this. First, those of us who were alive and "witnessed" all of these events first hand, did so through television. Most people had one (and usually only one)and TV was THE direct connection to all things Spaceworthy. But,second, not everyone watched the same newscaster;Conkite was CBS, Jules Bergman was on ABC and David Brinkley was on NBC. The Seaborn character is a wonderful almagam of all of these journalists and provides continuity between the episodes of the series without having to deal with old, grainy and in many cases just plain non-existent examples of the actual news coverage.

reply


By that logic, why not blend some of the astronauts together into "a wonderful amalgam" of just one astronaut?

reply

By that logic, why not blend some of the astronauts together into "a wonderful amalgam" of just one astronaut?


Because it's From the Earth to the Moon. And therefore a telling of the astronauts' flights to the moon. Perhaps if it was News At Five Reporting Live From The Moon they could blend the astronauts into one character and have time to feature each and every journalist that covered the programme. Just thinkin' out aloud.

reply