MovieChat Forums > From the Earth to the Moon (1998) Discussion > How many Apollo astronauts have you met?

How many Apollo astronauts have you met?


It's a thrilling experience, ain't it??

I've met Walt Cunningham, Jim Lovell, Rusty Schweickart, Gene Cernan, Buzz Aldrin, Alan Bean, Dick Gordon, Ed Mitchell (several times), Al Worden (twice), and Charlie Duke. I've been in the same room with Jim McDivitt and Tom Stafford, but didn't get the chance to meet them. I had dinner with Ed Mitchell, and this weekend I'm going to have lunch with John Young and Charlie Duke.

On the whole, I think From the Earth to the Moon was very well cast -- ESPECIALLY that dead ringer who played Frank Borman -- but I chuckle every time I see Gary "Bill Lumbergh" Cole as Ed Mitchell. He does a fine job playing a competent astronaut, but he's not very Ed Mitchellish. I thought their Deke Slayton was a bit dumpy, though he played the part well.

Collin R. Skocik

reply

I regret I have never met any astronauts, though I'd love to, given the chance.

The closest I've come is reading the books written by the astronauts themselves and learning a lot about their lives before and after the program as well as their thoughts at the time. Two of the best I've seen so far are Deke Slayton's autobiography "Deke!"; and "Two Sides of the Moon", which is a joint autobiography by Dave Scott and Alexei Leonov, each chronicling their side of the space race. I also recommend "A Man on the Moon", upon which this mini-series is based, even though it was not written by an astronaut. I also read Gus Grissom's book "Gemini!", finished just weeks before his death. Very eerie. He predicted that Gemini would continue in some form, though much of the things he probably predicted could be done with it would be done much later with the shuttle.

The actor who played Frank Borman was named David Andrews. Interestingly, he also played Pete Conrad in "Apollo 13", though I don't think he was a very good match for the latter role. I've been told Tom Amandes didn't look too much like Jack Schmitt. I've seen pictures of Jim McDivitt and actually think he looked a lot more like him.

I'd very much like to know what the real astronauts thought of the mini-series. Someone else posted on here that Al Bean enjoyed it. If it's ever come up what they thought of it, let me know, would you?

reply

I suggest you also read Chris Hadfield's 2013 autobiography, An Astronaut's Guide to Life on Earth (: What Going to Space Taught Me About Ingenuity, Determination, and Being Prepared for Anything). I saw Hadfield at a conference in 2015 and he is very personable, easy-going and accessible. The book is sheer joy, insight and enlightenment. Very modest and mature person. The type of guy we should send to space and an improvement on the only military type of earlier space missions. Astronauts are more well-rounded 50 years later, including personality and teamwork traits.

My dad was a consultant at CSA, so I met two other astronauts: charming and smart Julie Payette and brilliant Dafydd Williams, unfortunately before his 3 spacewalks!!! Both shared some nice insights one-on-one with me. It is a privilege and responsibility to be an astronaut and a privilege to interact with them.

Meet one if you can and share more on this interesting board.

(ps: I have not met Apollo astronaut but hope my post is still relevant and helpful)

reply

Not lunar mission Apollo, but Apollo-Soyuz, I met Vance Brand.

reply

I met Mike Collins (Gemini 10, Apollo 11) when he was director of the Smithsonian Air & Space Museum. I had lunch with Jack Lousma (Skylab 3, STS-3) in the '80s. I wish I had known at the time that he was the Apollo 13 CAPCOM when all hell broke loose. I would have love to talk with him about that. I saw Buzz Aldrin speak in 1996.

reply

I'd love to meet Mike Collins! Did you talk to him for long?

I've already acheived my life dream of meeting Buzz Aldrin and chatting with him for half an hour -- though I confess it wasn't enough! I could talk to him all night; he's a fascinating man.

But now I really want to meet Dave Scott, a personal hero of mine. Unfortunately I can't do a lot of traveling and he rarely, if ever, shows up at KSC. But you never know...if I keep attending these (expensive) autograph shows, sooner or later he's bound to show up.

Collin R. Skocik

reply

I'd love to meet Mike Collins! Did you talk to him for long?

Not more than a minute, unfortunately. This was ~30 years ago, and as a teenager I simply didn't have the knowledge to ask intelligent questions (I hadn't read his book, yet). It was a public event, anyway. We were in the Albert Einstein [planetarium] at the National Air & Space Museum. They were having an after-hours showing of Destination Moon, during which they showed slides of relevant real-world Apollo images as counterpoints to the events on the screen. It was a fun night!

reply

[deleted]

I also met Mike Collins, though I didn't talk to him long, and it was some years ago. I also heard him speak to an audience. He came off pretty much the same way he does in his book, I thought.

I shook hands with Dick Gordon and Pete Conrad, but I don't know if that counts as a meeting, since they were in motion and surrounded by lots of other people.

reply

So, Collin, have you ever asked any astronauts what they thought of the mini-series?

reply

"So, Collin, have you ever asked any astronauts what they thought of the mini-series?"

No, I've only had the chance to talk to them for a couple seconds, so I chose my questions/comments very carefully. I did talk to Buzz Aldrin and Ed Mitchell for quite some time, but somehow it just didn't seem appropriate to ask them what they thought of a miniseries when we were talking about orbital mechanics and landing radar and the nature of consciousness. Hopefully I'll get another chance to talk to them in depth this November, and maybe I'll find a chance to ask about it.

When I met Alan Bean, the woman in front of me told him how much she enjoyed the Apollo 12 episode. He told her a bit about how nervous Dave Foley was about getting the accent right. I got the impression Bean had not seen the episode, because if I heard correctly, he asked her "So did he do a good job?" I didn't hear her answer.

Collin R. Skocik

reply

Only Jim Lovell. I got to talk to him for only about 30 seconds, though.

reply

I met Gene Cernan a couple of years ago and got his autograph, A real nice man who was the 'last man on the moon'.

reply

I met Jim Lovell as well. I met him when I was a child at I think a book signing, some few years after Apollo 13. I asked him about it, and got a one word, tough guy answer. I have his signature, but not on his book.

reply

I met neil armstrong. And John Glenn, even though he was not an apollo astronaut.

reply

[deleted]

I've met only one astronaut, Dr. David Wolf (http://www.jsc.nasa.gov/Bios/htmlbios/wolf.html). We had him as a speaking guest for 2 years (or was it 3) for an annual convention we used to run in the '90s. He was always pleasant and quite knowledgeable and the attendees always enjoyed his presentations and Q&A sessions.

My apologies for being slightly OT as Dr. Wolf is not an Apollo astronaut.

reply

My husband and I were able to meet several that were up at a (very expensive) autograph show in Burbank, CA in September 2004. The highlights were Buzz Aldrin and Gene Cernan, with Scotty Carpenter, Wally Schirra, and Gordo Cooper right behind. Also, two others on the important ground crew. We both were pleased that we'd taken the time to meet Wally and Gordo, since we've lost them since then. At that one, they had 3 from the Hollywood realm of "space", as well: Bill Daily, Richard Kiel, and one of the Lost in Space crew.

It's very important to know that Buzz Aldrin will either not sign anything already signed by Neil Armstrong, or will charge 200% more. It cost us $150 to get his photo and autograph - but those who wanted his autograph on a photo already signed by Neil (who rarely signs them anymore) were going to have to pay $300 for that autograph at this particular show. He will only personalize them, too, which is good for you but puts a damper on people who want to sell them on eBay.

Anyone within driving distance of San Diego should check out:
http://www.spacefest.info

Spacefest 2009 will be held at the Town & Country in San Diego, in February 2009. More astronauts will be coming - there's a list on the website. Their Hollywood realm of "space" so far only has one from the original Battlestar Galactica series.


Donna

reply

> It's very important to know that Buzz Aldrin ...

Hmm.

Mike Collins will, so far as I can tell, sign anything (within reason ... he's an older guy nowadays).

Neil Armstrong will sign almost nothing, but at least he's fair. (An aside: I once had the opportunity to walk off with 20 original Neil Armstrong signatures -- on legal documents he signed as a director of a corporation -- but refrained from taking any).

Buzz Aldrin plays head games, or maybe they're business games.

reply

"It's very important to know that Buzz Aldrin will either not sign anything already signed by Neil Armstrong, or will charge 200% more. It cost us $150 to get his photo and autograph - but those who wanted his autograph on a photo already signed by Neil (who rarely signs them anymore) were going to have to pay $300 for that autograph at this particular show. He will only personalize them, too, which is good for you but puts a damper on people who want to sell them on eBay. "

That's really disappointing to hear. The guy only went into space because of the taxpayer, I think it's a bit of a backhanded gesture for him to be so selective. I can understand the personalization, which I also agree with. But 300 bucks is a bit much.

To be fair, maybe it was only at that event. It sounds like it was probably pretty swanky.

reply

He will only personalize them, too, which is good for you but puts a damper on people who want to sell them on eBay.


Good for him. Shame on anyone who'd try to make money that way anyway.

Spacefest 2009 will be held at the Town & Country in San Diego, in February 2009. More astronauts will be coming


Yeah, I'd love to go to that. Among others, there'll be a 40th anniversary reunion of the Apollo 9 crew: Jim McDivitt, Dave Scott, and Rusty Schweickhart.

If anyone here's going, ask Jim and Rusty what they thought of the mini-series, or say what they thought of the guys performing them. Dave, of course, was a technical advisor, so he might be a tad biased.

reply

My husband and I met Al Bean, Charlie Duke (so nice), Jim Lovell and Buzz Aldrin. We also met Guenter Wendt. How exciting! We actually named our cat Al Bean.

~I'm not okay, and you're not okay. But that's okay.~

reply

Did you ask any of them what they thought of the mini-series?

reply

In July 1970 I was a 16 year old Boy Scout and was honored to be part of the Hugh O'Brien/Boy Scouts Space Seminar. We spent a full week at the cape and I believe we met everyone and saw everything that it possible to do in a week.

I think this series does an excellent job of portraying the people of the program. One of the biggest things I came home with from that week was the understanding of the commitment to the program of everyone that worked there. I do not think it was just a job for anyone.

The Boy Scouts use some excerpts from the LEM design in the Wood Badge adult leader training course now.

reply

We went to go back and ask Al Bean what he thought of Dave Foley's portrayal of him but he was leaving then. He's the only one we thought to ask, I guess because he was so personable. Next time. : )

~I'm not okay, and you're not okay. But that's okay.~

reply

I met Jim Lovell. He signed my Life magazine. Shortly after Apollo 11 a park in my town was named Tranquility Park. Neil Armstrong came for the dedication and even brought some moon rocks. I was there for the dedication even though I was six or seven at the time. The whole town turned out and I saw Neil Armstrong from a distance. Still a thrill.

reply

Oh man, to see Neil would be a highlight of my life. I can respect that the man wants a private life though.

~Be God's~

reply

Sort of miss-cuts for me, I popped in toward the end of a Buzz Aldrin live lecture in a flight museum where I volunteered during High School, but had no chance to meet him. I also had an opportunity to meet Fred Haise later on, but I was out of town. Yet I did do an interview with Janet Kavandi(Not Apollo, but still cool), strictly for student archives though

reply

I met James Irwin of Apollo 15, who is sadly no longer with us. He came to give a talk at my school in the UK. (I think it was 1979). I asked him what he thought of the Apollo-Soyuz mission. He said he wasn't too keen on it because he didn't trust the Soviets, and didn't like them getting hold of US technology.

I've never forgotten the thrill of shaking the hand of someone who has stood on the lunar surface.

reply

Well, the Cold War was still going on at the time, so there was still a lot of suspicion on both sides. Perhaps he would have been a bit more mellow about it in later years, had he lived longer. His commander Dave Scott actually worked on the mission in a management position.

reply

[deleted]

Edgar Mitchell (handshake, autograph, and photo for free). It was a thrill.

reply

Was it a "special thrill"? (anyone familiar with episode 11 will know what I'm referring to!) Seriously, I would love to talk to any of the Apollo astronauts, but especially Jim Lovell, who seems so personable and sincere. And time, sadly, is running out. For all of us from that era, but it is bittersweet that those few who have walked on another world will in the next couple of decades at most no longer be able to speak on it. Especially in view of all the jealous bitter wackos who can't wait to see them go so they can promote their conspiracy agendas, and may they rot in hell.

reply

It was a special thrill for me, cos these heroes are rolemodels for me. I could only say to Mr. Mitchell that it is an honour to met him and that was it. There were people around him everywhere, I was afraid they will crush him. He was surrounded like a rock star. He gave a small lecture to the audience as well.
So for me it was a once in a lifetime experience, especially cos I live far away from America.

reply