MovieChat Forums > Titanic (1997) Discussion > What's this ship smell like

What's this ship smell like


Strange question right?


Just watching it tonight when jack walks into the 1st class area for the first time there seems to be a little haze in the air. you know what it's like today to be somewhere near someone smoking. Here ? Everyone is smoking everywhere and they even have a smoking room. Have to imagine that smell throughout the ship.


can't imagine the ship vented enough either to get the smell out. Or would the saltwater smell be throughout the ship? 2nd class and steerage stinking the place up below.

reply

I'm old enough to remember when smoking was every-freaking-where. You go into any room anywhere and there was a haze of cigarette smoke. Every house had ashtrays in every room. But you know what? If you lived in that era you would be used to it and not really smell it.

These days, if I'm driving behind a car where someone inside is smoking, I have to shut off my car's ventilation so I don't get a lungful. Amazing how things change.



Is very bad to steal Jobu's rum. Is very bad.

reply

Although I have never smoked in my life I have always liked the smell of someone's smoldering cigarette. I love when people smoke in movies. Especially women smoking. Simply adore. It looks beautiful. Hate to see people drinking alcohol and the stench is really disgusting. Rose was a smoker and she lived to be 101. Nowadays people are so afraid of smoking people whose smoke can reach their delicate nostrils, that is what scares ME.

reply

Although I have never smoked in my life I have always liked the smell of someone's smoldering cigarette.


Really?

I've never smoked either, but I grew up with parents who smoked cigarettes. Being around A single smoker doesn't bother me so much...most of the time. It's the concentration of smoke that gets to me. Being in the car with my parents smoking was too much. Or being in a room full of smokers where all you can see is a haze is too much for me too... I typically find that menthol cigarettes smell worse than regular brands for some reason.

I can't stand cigar smoke at all. It makes me want to throw up. Personally, I think they should be outlawed.

My Grandfather smoked a pipe, and that never bothered me, as I recall. Infact, I know that some brands of pipe tobacco, and even some that are like "Cherry" flavored or whatever, I actually like smelling those.

Odd. You would think tobacco would be the same from one kind of smoking to another, but it isn't.

I love when people smoke in movies. Especially women smoking. Simply adore. It looks beautiful.


Many people are attracted to various parts of a woman's body. Their feet. Their legs. Their breasts...

But, I find that I am attracted to the hands of a woman, and seeing a woman smoke is a way for me to see her beautiful hands.

But then, sometimes you see a woman smoke, and it almost is like it gives them great pleasure, and their body language can be a turn on too...

So it all becomes a mixed issue for me.

Seeing Women Smoke? Yes. Smelling Their Cigarettes? I'm Not Really Interested.

Watching vintage hollywood films with those beautiful legendary actresses, and watching Beautiful Kate Winslet smoke in that first scene... fits the bill perfectly for me...

Rose was a smoker and she lived to be 101.


Well, we know she only smoked a few times during the movie, and we don't know if she continued to do so afterwords.

It is said that if you quit at an early age, you can recover from the hazards of smoking...


However, I just read that Bette Davis smoked FIVE packs a day (FIVE Packs? Seriously? How?) for most of her life, and she lived into her 80s, when most people were only expected to live into their 60s or 70s. MANY classic hollywood stars who smoked also lived into their 80s... Yet, some people who never smoked in their life today, get lung cancer and die in their mid 30s.

Nowadays people are so afraid of smoking people whose smoke can reach their delicate nostrils, that is what scares ME.


This "TRUTH" about how bad tobacco is for you, seems to be more about scaring people, than anything else...

Now that doesn't mean that smoking isn't bad...

But I think genetics is more to blame, than tobacco. Some people just can't take it... And as I said, how do you explain non-smokers for getting lung cancer?

The part I hate to see is how smokers are treated when someone gets ONE puff blown in their face. They are NOT going to die from the occasional exposure.

If they don't want to be around smokers, then they just need to stay away from employee break rooms & bars!

If smokers want to risk their own health, they can step outside.



As for Titanic, Yeah, I would avoid the smoking lounges, and enclosed spaces where other passengers are smoking.

People smoked like chimneys in WWII. I even think crews smoked on Submarines. I may be wrong about that, but if I am not... Think about what THAT was like... At least people on Titanic, could open up a window! or go up on deck for some fresh air.

reply

FINALLY a sensible answer to the outrage of smoking, lol.

reply

I still remember when they allowed smoking in airplanes. I don't recall what year it was when all flights were made non smoking but it was definitely a welcome change.

reply

That is an interesting question but it's not strange.

I imagine it smelt like either what you described or maybe the smell of a library. I know that sounds random but libraries have a distinct smell to me. Maybe not the library itself, but the all books I guess.

reply

The smell of fresh paint. Imagine the smell of hundreds of cabins recently painted and varnished. Despite the bitterly cold weather some of the passengers and crew kept their porthole windows open. Survivor Mr. Stengel said he spoke to a fellow passenger who kept his porthole open when the iceberg passed by and "the ice came into his porthole". He was asked why it was open.

Q - Was there comment because of the fact that the porthole was open? Was there any special comment on that fact?

A - He just wanted air. He said, "I left my port hole open for air."

Q - And he got this ice?

A - He got some of the ice in there.


reply

[deleted]