Everyone was miscast
None of the actors/characters had any chemistry:
Helen and Gerry
Helen and James
Helen and her best friend Anna
Gerry and his "mate" from the pub - Gerry looks like a snobby middle class man whilst his friend in the pub was a cockney London geezer - no way would those two be friends in real life.
Gwyneth Paltrow does not pull off the "normal girl" role well, either.
Everything just seemed so contrived with this movie. The plot idea is good but the film just failed to deliver for me.
x