MovieChat Forums > Shiloh (1997) Discussion > The book definatly a read

The book definatly a read

posted 18 years ago by spidermonkey85
2 replies | jump to latest

Shiloh the book by Philis Renolds Naylor was SOOOOOO good I can't stress how great it is..If you haven't read it pick up the whole Trilogy

Shiloh
Shiloh Season
Saving Shiloh

I hated THE MOVIES why because it just wasn't like the books.
I read all of the Shiloh books and GOD..they were so good and my heart just went out to the poor beagle especially when Judd Travers beated the dog. :-(.
I have a beagle dog and if it had been a boy I would of named it after him.

LOVE LOvE LOVE the books. check em out!! Also good for young readers.

[–] sabre_unlimited 17 years ago

You should never expect movies based on books to be like them. That is just idiotic.

[–] Danny-Sichmeller 8 years ago

What are you talking about? Plenty of books were made successful by sticking to the plot.