MovieChat Forums > Savior (1998) Discussion > Re: Serbian Propaganda

Re: Serbian Propaganda


I confess I am a Westerner, basically ignorant of the politics of this war.

As a movie viewer, I think it is superb and do not see how it is a propaganda film for any side in the slightest bit! It is an anti-war film, period.

The old couple that helped Joshua and the Serbian woman were Croats, and showed them the most generous hospitality. The film makes its main point when we first are introduced to them when the old man said (in my poor paraphrase): Before the war, we were Croats, Serbs, Muslims, no matter, we were all neighbors, but now.....

And later, the elderly couple "spiritually adopted" these three when they told them goodbye. The old man gave his dead son's clothes to Joshua and the old woman kissed and blessed the girl and the baby with so much love and tears. It was a very beautiful and moving illustration of the universality of man.

To me, an outsider, the film is saying that human life is tremendously important, and war is an insane thing-- and it makes you question why on earth people do this! Value for human life, even in the midst of war, is shown through Joshua's defense of these strangers (this baby and her mother) no matter what risks there are to his own life. We slowly learn that he realizes this war is madness and he is somehow atoning for partaking in it himself.

I think it is a wonderfully pro-life, anti-war movie. Not propaganda at all, in my view.



reply

Thank God someone got this movie right...

reply

I share your oppinion 100%

reply

[deleted]

The film is not Serb propaganda, Its an anti War film using a war that easily shows the mentality of people who are basically born and brought up with mistrust and maybe even hatred of others.
It is showing what happened in a very complicated war,
yes, Serbs committed atrocities against the Bosnian Muslims and Croats, but also (as the film shows) the Bosnian Croats and Muslims commited atrocities against Serbs and even against each other, in that sense it is a very good film.

reply

one way or another, this arguments about Serbs, Croats and Bosnians who atrocited who will go to eternity. All three has to put that behind and continue without arguments.
Oh, and movie is just an awful truth of what hapened there...

reply

Serbs committed atrocities against the Bosnian Muslims and Croats, but also (as the film shows) the Bosnian Croats and Muslims commited atrocities against Serbs and even against each other, in that sense it is a very good film.

it's the unevenly distributed ratio of atrocities which makes blaming all three sides equally impossible.

reply

[deleted]

But it's accusations and recriminations that keep a war going and lead to countless innocent deaths. Deal with it, move on, live life in peace and happiness!

reply

I agree, this movie does not take any other side, than the side against war.

People who say otherwise should watch it again.

reply


it's the unevenly distributed ratio of atrocities which makes blaming all three sides equally impossible.

I don't think you can really quantify atrocities that easily.

If all the sides were committing them, the question of capability and scale are irrelevant.

reply

[deleted]

[deleted]

But Serbia did not kill off the Croats living in Serbia - nor destroy Catholic churches, nor even fire them from their jobs.

Croatia sent soldiers into Bosnia from the start of the war and had brigades stationed there all throughout the war.

Croatian soldiers did kill Bosnian Serb civilians at the beginning of the war near the border with Croatia.

The wars were started by Croats and Muslims who wanted to kill off the Serbs in Croatia and Bosnia.

The Bosnian Muslims had themselves named after Bosnia to make everyone believe it's their territory, when in fact, Serbs lived there before the Muslim religion came.

Serbs outnumbered Muslims in Bosnia until only a few decades ago. Austrian census in the late 1800's had Serbs as over 40% and Muslims as just over 30%.

reply

[deleted]

It was admitted that Croats killed their own police officers just before Operation Storm in order to blame the Serbs and spark the start of that operation. They admitted it at the ICTY court. And Tudjman did have plans to ethnically cleanse out the Serb population of Croatia before the war. Croats started the war to get rid of the Serb population.
Serbia did not ethnically cleanse its Croatian population which still has the same numbers after the wars as before. Serbia did not blow up or destroy Catholic churches in Serbia and it did not even fire ethnic Croats and Muslims from their jobs.

The wars were started by western backed separatists who saw the Serb population and Yugoslav army as in the way for little "independent" statelets to be absorbed into the EU and western dictates.

reply

[deleted]

[deleted]

You have guests because of great coastline (duh!) - not the people. The land, the sea are very beautiful; the people are cold and small minded. And actually you have been having a dip in tourism this year - and Croatia is even trying to get Serb tourists back like from the prewar times. But I say the Serbs that go back are wrong - they are enablers of evil Croatia.

reply

[deleted]

[deleted]

[deleted]