How did he know???


How did "Elvis" (Keitel) know all those detailed facts about the sheriff's childhood????

reply

Good question

reply

It's not quite stated, but it seems as though it is elvis's spirit that is there to help jonathan schaech's character.

reply

This is key or pivotal in the film.

-in other words,he could not "snow" this incident because of its preciseness.

-mby

reply

You've hit the nail right on the head.

In the first scene that everyone seems to have forgotten about, 'Elvis' is seen with the train driver who is now a truck driver and he appears to have sorted out his head by allaying the guilt he had for colliding with the car and killing the girl. 'Elvis' then sought out jonathan schaech's character and did the same for him.

He obviously couldn't have known about the cop's childhood and at that point in the film the audience are puzzled. At the end it is clear that it's Elvis' spirit within Keitel that is helping everyone out. That is the whole point of the film. When he meets the hobo on the train at the end he is obviously going to sort out his life too. Whether this was because the hobo was on the train involved in the original accident or whether 'Elvis' is going to sort out the reason why he's a hobo in the first place isn't clear.

reply

Yes but spirits do not age. Elvis in order to be an older man as a ghost or spirit of himself would have once had to have been an older man in his lifetime but he never was an old man in 1977 or earlier. Therefore no spirit "footprint" would have been made. There would never in a million years be a spirit of a senior aged Elvis walking around. Can you see the ghost of your dead child as an old man when he never even lived to adulthood?

reply

The fake 'Elvis' played by Harvey Keitel is a real person in the movie: He was an Elvis impersonator when Elvis was still alive. On the same day Elvis died in 1977 the fake Elvis's wife & son were killed in a plane crash and he turned mentally ill with grief, convinced that he was the real Elvis. At some point after Elvis' death, his ghost started using the mentally ill 'Elvis' (Keitel) to help people to heal and provide low-key guidance.

reply

If I understand your position, somehow the redundancy over their deaths and the mistaken identity lead to a paranormal Elvis impersonation. As perhaps the real Elvis - beyond the grave, mind you - somehow pitied the mere show actor Elvis? Of course call him a fake, and he'd say "Don't be silly", then he demonstrates mental capability so it's almost simpler to believe his death was faked. The movie hints whatever it's on this man.

reply