MovieChat Forums > As Good as It Gets (1997) Discussion > Why did Verdell choose Melvin over his o...

Why did Verdell choose Melvin over his owner ?


I believe that Verdell chose Melvin because Verdell knew Melvin needed him more. Would love to hear other opinions

reply

Because dogs love the last person who was nice to them or fed them.

reply

In real-life, yes. In a well written piece of fiction there is a reason

reply

Seemed pretty obvious to me.

Even though Simon liked him and valued the dog very much, it seemed like Melvin and the dog had a real and deeper connection, and became dependent on each other in the time they spent together.

reply

I thought it was only for comical effect, to make the audience smile.

reply

Crazy that I wrote this 2 years ago and it becomes relevant in my life now. I moved to Vegas just before everything shut down. My new landlord/roommate got laid off and has been working in Cali so I have been staying with her dog, the cutest, sweetest boxer in the world. With bars and such closed I rarely leave the house and don't have many friends out here, its just me and the dog, all the time. Away from family and so many close friends that I am used to being around, it has been the loneliest time of my life. Without this dog I certainly would have given up on a dream of a new life and moved back home by now, she is a Godsend. My roomie jokes that she is upset her dog loves me more than her now. She says she is joking but I always say "there is a little truth to every joke" I tell her what my mom has always said "love is not bound" Its ironic that since I started this thread 2 years ago, I overheard my mother on speaker phone one night when she was asked which one of her 3 boys does she love the best. She replied... well, I always say I love them the same and I do, but I think I do love one the best sometimes, it's whichever one needs you the most at the time. I explained to roomie that this is why her dog may appear to love me more, I need her tremendously right now. With her mom being gone, she has also needed me and I think that makes me love the dog even more.
With all respect to the other responses, I don't think Verdell appeared to love Melvin more than Simon for comical effect and I don't think it was because Melvin was the last person to love or feed him. Melvin had noone in his life that loved him and needed Verdell more than anyone. I think it was a very well written way to purvey this fact.

reply