Deaf and Mute?


During the King of the Fools contest, we are informed that Quasimoto is both deaf (because of the constant bells ringing in his ears) and mute.

Less than a minute later, he is laughing and saying "Thank you, thank you!" to his throng of adoring fans.

Huh?! Are we supposed to believe that he was so overwhelmed by Esmeralda's beauty and the cheering of the crowds (which he can't even hear!) that his hearing miraculously returned and he can now speak? Unbelievable, stupid, and unbelievably stupid.

reply

Maybe they were implying he had selective mutism. But wait a minute, was he supposed to be mute? I need to see this again. I was so sleepy when I watched it the first time but was determined to make it through, haha. I guess they mentioned that when he told her about the bells making him deaf?

reply

What? No. I realize that they didn't beat the audience over the head with the following, but I still felt like it was the obvious conclusion to make:

The film NEVER "informs" us or shows us that Quasimodo is mute. The crowd assumes that he is both deaf and dumb. One of the themes of this movie (I don't know about the book as I haven't read it) is how people assume so many things about Quasimodo because of his appearance. When he speaks, that's our first clue that he's not what he seems. He's not a freak at all but brilliant, brave, and kind, but nobody but those in the church are aware of it because he stays away from the public. He slowly reveals his true self to Esmeralda (and in doing so, reveals himself to the audience as well.)

No, he cannot hear the crowds, but he has eyes in his head. He might not have understood what was going on at first because he's deaf and he was just hauled up on stage out of the blue, but then Esmeralda puts a crown on his head and they put him on a throne, so I think he figured it out. He relaxes and enjoys the festivities - he's included in something for the first time in his life.

"I don't want to make money. I just want to be wonderful."

reply

It's been years since I've read the book, but from what I remember, Quasimodo goes deaf at an early age from living in the bell tower and it takes painstaking effort for Claude Frollo to teach him to speak and read lips.

Nevermore!

reply

Indeed, i imagine that plot point is more to show their relationship, since as far as the story goes, Frollo's painstaking work did pretty well all things considered.

Gamefaqs has a far worse population than IMDB

reply