The REAL Bumpy


Although this movie was entertaining, it was, indeed, factually inaccurate in many, many respects, not the least of which is in trying to make Bumpy Johnson a "humane" character.
In fact, Bumpy was from South Carolina, moving to NY and never being anything but a criminal. He was a true thug (with a capital 'T'), resorting to serious violence -- albeit fearlessly -- at the least (even presumed or imagined) provocation. If I recall correctly, he once even stormed into a police station (or was it the hospital), shooting (killing?) a man there, due to the fact that the man (victim) had survived Bumpy's earlier attempt to kill the man.
He was truly violence personified.
That being said, he did use some of the power he acquired (due to people fearing him) to help out the less powerful in the Harlem community, e.g., forcing the Cotton Club to hire some, including certain black musicians.
He also used it to help Ms. St. Claire (the character of "The Queen" who, prior to the mob trying to take over, alone held sway over the numbers game in Harlem).
This did, in fact, put Bumpy in direct confrontation with "Dutch" Schultz ... and that violent part of the movie is true.
I think it would have made an interesting movie to have simply focused on his terribly violent and unrepentant character, for his REAL story is actually pretty compelling.
It also would've added enough elements that ridiculous fictions (e.g., Thomas E. Dewey being on the take from "Lucky" Luciano, "Dutch" Schultz being gunned down by his own henchman, etc.) wouldn't have had to be included.

reply

Why is Dewey being on the take so hard to believe?lol

reply

Because he wasn't on the take. Shultz wanted to tkae dewey out and the commission was going to go along with it, until louis lepke buchalter talked them out of it. Schultz was still going to try and he was hit in part by murder inc.

reply

harlem Godfather

reply

Lepke didn't talk The Commission out of anything. Only member that agreed with Schultz was Albert Anastasia.

Short Cut, Draw Blood

reply

Why is Dewey being on the take so hard to believe?lol


Because he wasn't. Even Luciano (who hated Dewey) never stated that. Luciano had nothing to hide in that if Dewey was in fact on the take. Luciano wrote his memoirs (The Last Testiment Of Lucky Luciano)that weren't to be published until 10 years after his (Luciano's) death, and if Tommy Lucchese was still alive, another 10 years. And he never said anything about that.

reply

Another major inaccuracy concerns the occasion of Dutch Schultz getting into the Harlem numbers game in the first place. It wasn't through violence at all.

One of the major numbers bankers, Jamaican-born Joseph "Spasm" Ison, was unable to pay off winners and came to Schultz for a bail out. Schultz agreed, on condition he get a piece of the business. In the end, through superior organization and some trickery, he wound up with all of it.

Schultz's man Otto "Abadaba" Berman was said to be a mathematical genius who would make a big bet at a local racetrack and throw off the winning number if it seemed the Schultz bank would take a hit.



["We have all strength enough to bear the misfortunes of others./"]
--La Rochefoucault

reply

True, Bumpy Johnson was probably alot more ruthless like the portrayal of him in the Across 110th Street.

That Jamaican you are referring to (Joseph "Spasm" Ison) was potrayed by Delroy Lindo in the movie (and mentioned in the autobiography) Malcolm X. Kind of funny how he wasn't even mentioned in Hoodlum.

"When people do not have a past, they must create myths to supplement the facts of their existence"

reply

"When people do not have a past, they must create myths to supplement the facts of their existence". Well said. Happens all the time, pathetic and loudmouthed losers howling on the streets, in Sinbad the Sailor costumes claiming to be decedents of "lost tribes of Israel" among them, signifying nothing come quickly to mind. Or, I might add, when their pasts are so shameful they cannot bear them without retreating into cheap cartoon-like fantasy - fooling if anybody, themselves. And BTW, there is no need to put quotes around "Dutch" alone, "Schultz" is also a part of his nom de guerre. We (should) all know his birth name was Arthur Flegenheimer of the Bronx. A nice Jewish boy in the bootlegging and murder for hire business, made possible by the ladies auxiliary of uptight WASPS of America and a protege of the founding father of American organized crime, Mr. Arnold Rothstien. Say hallelujah, say amen. ;)

reply