Pierrot le fou


I had an epiphany today about Hana Bi.
I was watching Jean-Luc Godard's Pierrot le Fou for the umpteenth time and a shot of Anna Karina marching down a beach with a crimson fish on a spear made me think of Kitano's Sonatine and the speared fish in that film. I'd read an interview with Kitano where he'd mentioned he was a great admirer of Godard, so the visual reference didn't come as a surprise. But it made me think about Kitano's other films, and I realized that Hana-Bi is practically a remake of Pierrot le Fou. Think about it. A man steals a great deal of money and goes on the run with his lover, chased by both the police and organized crime. The centerpiece of the film is the couples relationship, made all the more touching by the contrast to the sudden and shocking moments of violence that intrude into their lives. Cut into the film are paintings (in Hana-Bi, Kitano's own, in Pierrot, Modigliani's and Renoir's). The films climax with a murder-suicide where the protagonist kills his lover and then himself, followed by the camera's slow pan out into the ocean.
One more similarity, this one bizarre, and in all likelihood coincidental. Both Godard and Kitano underwent immense physical and artistic transformations following tragic motorcycle accidents.

reply

Really interesting when you think about it. No wonder I like both films so much.

reply

Huh, awsome this is just another reason for me to watch Pierrot le fou.

reply

I'm huge fan of Kitano , but I really don't care for Godard or Pierrot le fou. Interesting similarities , though they are two extremely different film makers.

reply

ditto - can't be arsed with goddard, but as ive found with alot of film makers that admire goddard; his style is better filtered through their sensibilities...so by proxy i like his work - but not outright!

reply

Kitano and Godard have a LOT in common, specifically: Characters staring directly into the camera, the use of sweeping dramatic string scores (I know that's kind of a bad description, but there are LOTS of similarities between the soundtracks these two men constantly use), and bright, vibrant colors. DOLLS also seems like it could be a later-period Godard film, albeit a bit more linear. Godard is one of my top 5 directors, definitely, and Pierrot Le Fou is in my top 10 films, definitely. I do enjoy Kitano more, though, because I think he takes the best elements of Godard and does something more interesting with them. Sacriligious, but true.

reply

While agreeing with the OP, I must add that there is one glaring difference between the two great filmmakers, in that Takeshi seems actually to care about his characters.

Listen to the river sing sweet songs
to rock my soul

reply

Your point intrigued me a lot, however you just spoiled the ending of Pierrot Le Fou for me and I really really hate having endings spoiled. Please put a warning on this post. :(

reply