MovieChat Forums > Le bossu (1998) Discussion > The French know how to do a swashbuckler

The French know how to do a swashbuckler


It seems like everything works in this movie. The plot zips along nicely, never lagging; the writing's very tight, with some great one-liners and exchanges; the period setting is developed to near perfection, with fantastic locations and costumes... I could go on.

The big question on my mind now is, where is the great French adaptation of Dumas's immortal Troix Mousquetaires?

No adaptation that I've seen or heard of has actually stayed with the original mood and story of the book.

Granted, there's a lot in that book, but what I think would be nice would be a miniseries, English or French, that stuck to the book like pre-chewed gum to sneakers.

It's been done before. Look at the fabulous and still unequaled Pride and Prejudice with Colin Firth. Not to mention the Vanity Fair starring Natasha Little.

reply

"The Four Musketeers", directed by Richard Lester is the best I have seen (in English....sorry) Alexandre Salkind did a two-movie production with Michael York as D'Artagnan. I bought both for less than $20 American @ Amazon.com. Hope you like it. [email protected]

reply

There was an excellent silent version with Aimé Simon-Girard as d' Artagnan and, of course, the best of all, André Hunebelle's wonderful 1953 sizzler with Georges Marchal as d' Artagnan and the unforgettable Bourvil as Planchet. That was a great movie!

www.imdb.com/title/tt0046461/






If the Kingdom of Heaven is like a grain of mustard, It can also be like a chicken-pox mark.

reply

Lagardère (2003) (TV)
http://german.imdb.com/title/tt0397508

tells the same story but explains things better. I guess it's closer to the novel. The revenge-plot really took many years which is better illustrated in the TV movie.

reply