MovieChat Forums > Bent (1997) Discussion > A metaphor for purgetary or not that dee...

A metaphor for purgetary or not that deep?


Am i right in thinking that this is what the story meant? it's how i took it anyway.

Basically, it's all a big metaphor for purgetory.

From the moment Clive Owen chooses to disown all knowledge of his boyfriend on the train, who is subsequently murdered, he given a choice. To prove his hetrosexuality to the guards, or admit his real sexuality and choose to honour his lover. What follows in the film is his descent into purgatory, or the concentration camp. In here he is given the rock tasks which represent the endless struggle to come to terms with his guilt, and also the chance to make up what he did wrong in his life in this form of hell. This is where he meets his fellow prisoner, who gives him the chance to avenge his lovers death by avenging his new inmates death who he has fallen in love with. Thus ends the cycle of his purgotory with the end of his life (or was this really hell and was he already dead?)

Any thoughts please!

I did find this film hard to watch but found it very thought provoking.

reply

purgetary, purgetory, purgotory...

...hetrosexuality....

laugh out loud

reply

Got a problem with spelling errors?

could you please explain your comments.

reply

Well, Purgatory is generally regarded as a way-station in between Heaven and Hell. I would find it hard to think of the Holocaust as the waiting room, or means of redemption, for heaven.

reply

I like your purgatory metaphor. The Holocaust is a good place to set it in, though I think all its victims were screwed, regardless of their state of sins or redemption. Clive did get to resolve his guilt, though since the real Holocaust wasn't a morality play, he just got to suffer more and then die.

reply

Purgatory is where a loving God sends you for further maturing before entering Heaven.

Can you say that about Dachau?








If the Kingdom of Heaven is like a grain of mustard, It can also be like a chicken-pox mark.

reply

I like the idea of the stone moving task as a form of penance or learning during which he learns to love and accept his sexuality again.

An hour isn't an hour but a little bit of eternity in our hands

reply

In this film, "Dachau" is symbolic of Dachau. The "Gay Holocaust" in the film is symbolic of the Gay Holocaust.

It seems to me to be pitifully absurd to assume that these events in film must somehow be symbolic of something abstract in order to be "deeper," as you put it. Such symbology, had it been intended, could only have made the story shallower.

"I don't deduce, I observe."

reply