MovieChat Forums > Amistad (1997) Discussion > What is everyone's favorite scene?

What is everyone's favorite scene?


I know there aren't many posters here yet. But they will come. I'm sure of it...

I think the most touching scene of the film is the one in which Cinchey and another captive are interpreting the Bible based on the pictures they see. That was so incredible! I've never seen anything quite like that in a movie before. And I am quite positive that Spielberg is responsible for the existence of this scene.

The movie is filled with many highlights though. A funny scene is when the African is warning Mathew's character not to lift the sword too high. LOL..

What are some of ya'll's favorite scenes of the film?





I'm not a control freak, I just like things my way

reply

[deleted]

The whole movie's beautiful, frankly. But yeah, that seen is definitely excellent too. And it allowed Addams(Hopkin's character) a first-hand look at actual proof that Cinchey was in fact FROM where he said he was FROM: Africa

He recognized and identified the rare plant that was from Africa.

I love this movie..






I'm not a control freak, I just like things my way

reply

They aren't from "Africa". If you think this movie is so amazing and great why do you not even know the difference? Also the rare plant from Africa? Wow, you sound extremely dumb i'm sorry you watched this movie.

reply

I'm sorry, my dear friend, but it is infact you who sounds dumb. No, scratch that... extremely dumb.

Djimon Honsou's character was indeed from Africa. That was the whole point of the film (and the trial). Are you brain dead? And even if I was wrong, does that really give you the right to just come on here and hurl insults?

And yes, the flower that Anthony Hopkin's character had was indeed rare. You don't remember the line when he said "I can't tell you how difficult that was to come by..."


You're a moron, Nomad. But we appreciate your stopping by on the Amistad board. Keep it moving though. Much more for you to see here on IMDB...




I'm not a control freak, I just like things my way

reply

Wow, are you really that ignorant? I understand they are from Africa. You don't need to explain that to me, thats not what i was saying. But you refer to Africa as if it is one united society, which is "Extremely Dumb". Wow and to insult me by saying i am a Mormon - I don't even practice any religion. Besides, what would that have to do with anything?

If this movie touched you so greatly, how come you can't understand it. Do you even know what country the Amistad slaves came from, what language they spoke, what their customs/beliefs were? Or did you have one view of Africa. Rather than preeching the greatness of this movie (which it really isn't that great) you should do some history search on "Africa". Maybe have a little sense before you criticize me for trying to help you.

The whole point of the trail wasn't that they were from Africa. It was that the trial ignited the civil war, because it was in question that if the Amistad Rebllion slaves were freed, then legally, the rest of the slaves born outside of the country(who therefore would be exported illegally) would have to be given freedom and the right to go back to their home land. The point of the movie wasn't that they were "from Africa".

P.S That flower Adam's was holding is now extremely common

reply

There clearly seems to be a misunderstanding, and one I don't care to dive into with you. But I do want to comment on one thing.

The point of the trial WAS that they were from Africa. I'm not speaking of the aftermath. I'm speaking of this movie in particular. If it could be proven that the slaves were from Africa, then they would be freed. But if it wasn't possible to prove that the slaves were not from Cuba, then they would have been returned to their "owners" as "property."

That's really common knowledge as far as this film is concerned. Anyone who does not grasp this... well... you've missed the mark.




I'm not a control freak, I just like things my way

reply

thats pretty much what i said...um yea but the importance of this trial is the fact that it determined whether we would avoid going into a civil war or not. if they had been found to be given back to the spaniards, then the civil war might of been avoided.

reply

...I wasn't speaking of the importance of the trial. I was speaking of its purpose within this particular story. In reality, it's main importance was the provoking of the civil war.

if they had been found to be given back to the spaniards, then the civil war might of been avoided.
Well it doesn't matter because they were free men and they deserved to be sent back to their rightful homes. They weren't property. They were humans. Like Hopkins's character says... if it leads to a Civil War, then it leads to a civil war. But these men are humans and their freedoms shouldn't be sacrificed just to spare a nation of hypocritical white men a civil war.

With any luck, the North and South would have killed eachother's populations off, and then the Native American population could have multiplied, and we wouldn't have the America of today. Too bad it didn't happen this way.




I'm not a control freak, I just like things my way

reply

what are you talking about? haha i think any historian would laugh at your ideas...you seriously have no idea what you're saying. the only reason they were found free was because slave-holding was illegal. please do some research!!!

reply

My hypothetical, hostile "idea" obviously flew over your head. It was pure fiction, but my own fantasy. Just hope that time machines aren't invented some day..





I'm not a control freak, I just like things my way

reply

My favorite scene would have to be when Baldwin is trying to explain to Cinque that the case has been appealed to the Supreme Court even though he had already told him that he was free, ending with Cinque's emotional breakdown, stripping off his clothes as he stands in front of the bonfire. What kind of place is this? Where you almost mean what you say? Where the laws almost work? How can you live like that?

reply

"You're a moron, Nomad."

"Wow and to insult me by saying i am a Mormon - I don't even practice any religion. Besides, what would that have to do with anything?"

DreTam2000 has been proven correct.

reply

Seriously, I can't imagine what has crawled up Nomad's rear. And truthfully speaking... I don't wanna know.




I'm not a control freak, I just like things my way

reply

When Baldwin tries to get Fala to show his filed teeth in the courtroom.

reply

[deleted]

...that scene was funny too. But um, Mathew's character's name was Baldwin in the movie? Damn, I haven't seen it in a while. I must have forgot. I never really paid attention to his character's name, I guess.






I'm not a control freak, I just like things my way

reply

The Bible interpretation scene with Cinque and another captive is quite moving, in my opinion one of the best scenes in the whole movie. It's been quite a few years since I saw the movie but I like the scene with Anthony Hopkins at his home with Morgan Freeman and Anthony Hopkins say's this line "whoever tells the best story wins" then later on in that scene he asks Morgan Freeman "Nooooo, what is THEIR story" meaning who are they as a people. Great movie, will become a classic in due time.



Have a better one :-).

reply

When they first destroy the slave-fort at the end of the film, and then laconically confirm it does indeed not exist! That was so great.

reply






I'm not a control freak, I just like things my way

reply

[deleted]


I agree with thepoet26
that scene really made my stomach turn...and I can't believe someone in my class laughed at that...I was so close to hitting them.
I had nightmares of that scene for days after watching it

Another mess of vampires, masquerade of sadistic pride...

reply

You have good restraint. I wouldn'tve been able to hold myself back.

reply

I loved the part where Cinque and the other African were looking at the pics in the Bible and the other guy understood the life and message of Jesus. That shows me that the Gospel can be understood by anyone!

reply

[deleted]

[deleted]

...a little sarcasm mixed with wit, I suppose.







I'm not a control freak, I just like things my way

reply

[deleted]

I love the bible scene too but I'm not sure what is the connection to the story?
Can somebody explain...

reply

...how blacks have turned to Christianity since our existence here in America. It displays how blacks have had no choice but to embrace it and relate to it somehow. Due to all the pain & suffering, blacks have turned to it. This happens when your main source of relief comes from the nearest religion in the region-- as well as the most abudant/influencial. When your only source of faith is represented in the form of a 0Bible, and is thrown in your face(much like it is thrown into the African's in the film) during your most crucial time of need, you're going to open up to it, and become receptive to the overall point and message of it-- which is "peace" and "positivity." The two things that most religions ultimately boil down to..

This positive message will captivate you and compell you, especially if you're at a crucial point of suffering in your life. And as a result, you get sucked in and become a Christian. The scene in the film shows it in a graceful and sentimental, tear-jerking way. However when looked at deeper, it shows how easily Christianity can be bestowed and persuaded onto a person. I dislike this, and so does Spielberg(him being Jewish-- as Jewish people have different believes from Christians), I'm sure(as the majority of Jews I've met in person indeed voice their dislikes of this as well). But I still absolutely love that scene in the film because it's so innocent and fits so perfectly. I love how it explains a whole lot in such a little, less-than-ten-minute scene in a movie. It touches my heart every time.








I'm not a control freak, I just like things my way

reply

My favorite scenes are...

1)When the slaves take over the ship and how one of the African men take the helm and keep spinning it around and looking up at the star lit sky.

2)When John Quincy Adams and Mr.Wright are walking down the steps and Adams spots a coin and makes Mr.Wright stop and pick it up lol.

"Hi, I'm Johnny Knoxville, and we're about to test my Rocket Skates!"




reply

I just watched the movie for the first time, and i thought the most moving scene was towards the beginning when Cinque realized that the amistad had been steered toward america and he was going to be captured. he jumped in the water and was trying to swim towards the sun (Africa). I thought it was the most beautiful and touching moment in the movie.

reply

I really liked the scene when Baldwin and Cinque were trying to communicate and each were saying the same thing in their own language. It really stood out for me. I also loved all the courtroom scenes (especially the last one). There was some awesome monologues delivered.


The Hardest thing in this World is to Live in it

reply

[deleted]