Was Joey really THAT gorgeous?
I remember jumping on the bandwagon with all the other girls in my 8th grade class and thinking Katie Holmes was soooo pretty, but was she really?
Now, when I look at her, I think she was average, maybe slightly above. She really did sell the girl next door look well, but ridiculously beautiful, not so much. She was cute, that's it. Yet Dawson and Pacey talked about her like she was some sort of goddess, and after season 2 it was like pretty much every guy she met thought she was amazingly beautiful or fell in love with her.