MovieChat Forums > The Whole Wide World (1996) Discussion > Get thee to the Hallmark channel!

Get thee to the Hallmark channel!


I didn't like it.

It wasnt horrible but the mediocre treatment of Howard's life story is a little insulting. But that's Hollywood, right?

I understand it's through the eyes of this woman he knew. Nonetheless, the screenwriters, it seems, made little to no effort researching the man's work.

So what you get is an account of Howard, third hand, from a woman who didn't write about him until forty years after the events.

I came to this film expecting some of the fire from those stories he wrote to come through in his character on the screen. This is not how it was.

After enough of "girl" and "yarn", I was consistently reminded of George W. Bush every time D'onofrio opened his big dumb mouth. Generally, if you're poor, from the South, and have any kind of education, you try to avoid acting like that. I am all three and I know I do. This is why I don't wish to believe REH could ever seem as big a meathead as D'Onofrio does in this flick. It wasn't so much the content of the dialog but the delivery.

But as the ending of the film makes plain, this movie was not made for me but for Renee Zellweger and "Jesse Stone" fans. This is why there is the Hallmark channel. The true character of the writer, Howard, was never important, only the woman who loved that poor troubled man! WAH! Because, hey, he's dead!

reply

i love Howards work & i enjoyed watching this film.
the two things are completely different.
i am unsure if it is an accurate portrayal of the great man Howard,but it was good to hear from somebody that knew him & attempted to put flesh & bone on him.
i do not think the movie was made to cash in on Howard's name,& i do not think the book was written just to cash in.Bare in mind,Novalyne Price was a novice writer & probably felt obligated to bring Howard back to life through words.
I would like to know just how close the book & the film are.
I think the "girl" & "yarn" comments although dumb were correct.Howard was trying to pretend to be one of his creations.If you look at an individual Conan story you might think it is an impressive read,but when you look at the Conan saga on a whole it is on an enormous scale.A hell of a lot of time must have been spent there by Howard.
Truth be told,we will never know Howard.He is gone forever.We only have written words to describe his personality & photos.
I get the impression by what i have read about him by other authors that he was a great person,& that is what counts.

reply

Writers who knew Howard were almost unanimous in calling him a weak "mama's boy" who lived in his imagination. My understanding is that D'Onofrio's performance and the writers' depiction of him are spot on.


"The value of an idea has nothing to do with the honesty of the man expressing it."--Oscar Wilde

reply