MovieChat Forums > Thinner (1996) Discussion > Billy's other options..

Billy's other options..


If Billy didn't have Ginelli to turn to for help what do you think he would have done after confronting the gypsies at their camp?

reply

He definitely would have given up or tried to reason with them by offering money. He was ready to end it even with Ritchie helping him when they discovered the dead guy in the car at the motel.

reply

He could've gotten all his corrupt buddies to keep hassling them, road violations, the RSPCA for fighting dogs, calling child welfare....the white man from town has heap big power


reply

True or worse just off them all

reply

And risk a dozen other innocent people being cursed because of him?

reply

All of his corrupt buddies were also cursed.

reply

His corrupt buddies only have power in that small town. The Gypsy's were well out of the reach of any legal authority. Billy was going to beg for his life and then die. Richie was a good friend to look out for Billy like that. He was a better friend then his cheating wife anyway.

reply

His wife was obviously cheating on him for sure and that is why I think Billy wanted revenge because in retrospect her actions in the vehicle could have been to misdirect Billy shortly after beginning an affair with the doctor.

reply

What could he have done

He was already at 120 pounds. I think he was desperate and felt he had no other options which is why he went to richie. He even tried to ask him not to hurt anyone.

reply

Died of infection, shock and blood loss without Richie's almost doc.

reply

Also, couldn't any of those gypsies have used their supernatural powers to flush out Ginnelli's character as soon as he started to attack them or were they extremely limited in that department?

reply

That felt like a plot hole for sure. How could the beautiful gypsy lady hear what they men were saying about her sexually in the office? She couldn't without supernatural perception. Perhaps the true dark heart of the Italian Mafia guy was immune from her Jedi powers?

reply

Her power seemed more like a spider sense to me and besides she was much younger than the old-Lempke. Perhaps they can't use their magic when they have the fear response of being shot at and need to be calm to use it.

reply