MovieChat Forums > Tesis (2016) Discussion > Evidence of influence by Hitchcock?

Evidence of influence by Hitchcock?


I'm writing a critique about Tesis right now and was considering the possible influence of Hitchcock on Amenabar... Would anyone else say that the thesis in this film is a MacGuffin? It is something constantly mentioned throughout the film, but that is not a truly material aspect of the plot. Also, I think there is definite evidence of voyeurism here, though not a great deal of dramatic irony. And aside from all this, was also wondering why people think Amenabar chose to have a poster of My Own Private Idaho on Angela's bedroom wall.

Discuss.

Thanks!

reply

I think there are many ways in which TESIS/AmenĂ¡bar show the influence of Hitchcock,
but I don't think that Angela's thesis/dissertation is a MacGuffin.

A MacGuffin is merely a device to set the plot in motion and create suspense,
some sort of secret formula or contraption or conspiracy--the exact nature of it has no impact on the story, as you have noted.

The important thing is that everyone wants it or is afraid of it or whatever.

Well, Angela's dissertation is more meaningful than that. She is truly fascinated by her subject matter--violence--and it leads her to fall in love with a guy who is so totally wrong for her that she may not survive the relationship. She gets carried away with her research and it transforms her perception of reality. Angela and her thesis can be compared to Don Quijote and his chivalry novels.

But you find Hitchcock in other aspects of the film: the chase sequences, the paranoia surrounding sexuality, the theme of watching and being watched (like REAR WINDOW), the uncertainty over who is good and who is evil (like SUSPICION), the attraction to evil (SHADOW OF A DOUBT), etc.

As for PRIVATE IDAHO, this is a very iconic film for gay men. AmenĂ¡bar is gay, so that could be part of the connection. It's been a long time since I've seen it; maybe someone else can find something more specific...

reply

After further consideration . . .

. . . although the thesis/dissertation itself is not a MacGuffin (see above), the search for the camera equipment is definitely MacGuffinish. So I would say whatever that ultra-rare camera was that they had to find, that was leading them to the killer, acted as a MacGuffin in this movie, and so you were on the right track.

Email me your critique please if you get a chance.

reply

When Chema pulled back the shower curtain I already had the Psycho soundtrack running in my mind.

reply

Given that Hitchcock created so many tropes of the thriller genre can anybody make a thriller and not be influenced by Hitchcock?

reply

This is a fair point, but I would say there are certainly come thriller makers who clearly attempt to create specific moments that are "Hitchcockian". In this film, there were a few points where I felt it was aiming for a "Frenzy" and "Rear Window" sort of setup, although I think they were not particularly successful. That said, the first half of the movie has some exciting use of mise-en-scene

reply