MovieChat Forums > Ponette (1997) Discussion > Why did Ponette's dad not raise her?

Why did Ponette's dad not raise her?


He clearly loves her, but he says something early on about his not being able to raise her by herself. And so he brings Ponette to her aunt's house, which I'm assuming is her mother's sister although I don't know for sure. Is he a traveling salesman or some other kind of person who has to travel a lot for his job? I don't fully understand the French system of education despite having seen this, Etre et Avoir, and L'Argent de Poche hundreds of times; but it would appear that Ponette went to a boarding school and maybe lived at her aunt's place on the weekends? She was clearly shown to be sleeping there overnight (inconceivable in the U.S. for such young children), yet the kids were talking about their parents at home as though they spent significant time there as well.

At the end of the film, Ponette is spending the whole day with her father, my impression being that it was a Saturday. So again, if she stays at a boarding school throughout the week, why not just live at her fathers house on the weekends? Despite his clear love for her, this and his not using seatbelts make me look somewhat askance at him as a father.

--------
See a list of my favourite films here: http://www.flickchart.com/slackerinc

reply

I'm in the USA and it does not seem that odd to me, personally. Just a couple generations ago, people with children, especially men, often remarried quickly when their spouse died - almost solely for the purpose of having someone take care of the children (or, provide the money to the household in the cases of women remarrying quickly).

I have a cousin who is the only child of divorced parents. She lived with her single mother until her mother died (when my cousin was about 5 years old). My uncle went out-of-state to get her and she moved in with our grandmother, almost immediately. He didn't travel for work and did not have a job that required extraordinary hours either. He (and his mother) just felt that the child would be better suited in an environment with a female role-model. I don't know if this would have been handled differently if my uncle had a son though.

I'm from Generation X and my parents and in-laws still believe in the "traditional gender roles" wholeheartedly. Historically speaking, it's a very, very "new" concept that fathers can be stay-at-home parents while the wife provides the family financial support.

reply

I got the impression that he had never been very present in her life. Maybe the parents were separated (it seemed that way because he didn't act like a grieving husband) and he didn't live close. And yes, I assume he had to leave for work. It does seem very bad form to leave your young daughter after her mum's death, which is why I assume the aunt had more of a relationship with her anyay.


I’ll be waiting, with a gun and a pack of sandwiches.

reply

I thought of the possibility that they were separated, but there is a line where he says something like "I thought she'd always be with us too."

--------
My top 250: http://www.flickchart.com/Charts.aspx?user=SlackerInc&perpage=250

reply