Fact-based movie?


I read somewhere that this was a fact-based movie, but then when I watched I found it was based on a Vonegut novel?

Is there a contradiction here?

reply

It was a Vonnegut novel, completely fictional. He wrote it as though it were a translation of an actual man's memoirs (what Campbell is typing throughout), and that he only served as the translator from German to English. This, however, is just a literary device. This story is pure Vonnegut, and, in my opinion, it's Vonnegut at his best.

reply

It is fictional, but I wonder whether he got the inspiration for Howard Campbell (an American writer who gives propaganda broadcasts for the Nazis) from Ezra Pound.

reply

[deleted]

My digital cable program said that the movie was based on the "True story of Howard W. Campbell Jr. , an American that spied on Nazi Germany during WWII"
I scoured the Internet to find out about this "true story", but found that my cable program was wrong, the story was fictional. I hate getting false information.
The character Howard W. Campbell DID appear in the novel Slaughterhouse Five.

reply

Don't trust everything you read on wikipedia. Any good scholar will tell you that half the information on that site is false. As for Kurt Vonnegut and Howard, Howard is writing as a real man in history but he is purely fiction. It is, as stated above, a genius literary technique. One that is captured in the book perfectly and pretty well in the movie.

Every writer is a frustrated actor who recites his lines in the hidden auditorium of his skull.

reply

There is precisely as much "fact" in Mother Night as a novelist with Kurt Vonnegut's insight into the human condition is able to instill in it. Read K.V. for a while, and you begin to hear echo's of La Rochefoucauld's injunction, "Some lies (fictions) are so carefully made to resemble the truth, that we would be poor judges of the truth if we did not believe them."
As Terell County Sheriff Bell (No Country For Old Men) tells Carla Jean, "Is it a True story? Well, it's True it is a story."
From reading comments about this movie it seems many people were "gulled" by this story, and they didn't like that experience. I say go to the library or book store and buy "Cat's Cradle" and keep reading K.V., you will not regret it.

reply

Even if we take the wikipedia article to be accurate, it says nothing about Joyce being a British spy working in Germany. He moved to Germany because he was into fascism, and he'd been in British fascist groups. He was an unrepentant anti-Semite. Maybe he was the inspiration in the sense that he was a non-German broadcasting propaganda for the Nazis, but the point of the book and film is that Campbell doesn't care about fascism or racism or governments or anything but his wife.

reply

Is it possible that the Campbell character was inspired by American poet Ezra Pound? According to http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ezra_Pound, the renowned literary man did a few anti semitic radio broadcasts in Italy and after the war had to stand trial in the United States for high treason.

reply

no, but i see how you would make the connection. Ezra was clinically insane during that period(if not earlier).

reply

[deleted]