MovieChat Forums > The Juror (1996) Discussion > good, but plot difficulties (spoilers)

good, but plot difficulties (spoilers)


While I thought this was a good thriller, I just couldn't get past the basic premise that a smart woman would immediately cave in to a mobster and do his bidding. He threatened to kill her son, but how could she think they wouldn't kill her anyway after the trial because she knew too much? Immediately going to the police, the court, the newspapers--raising a big commotion-- would be what I would do. She would have been believed, because threatening people is what the mob does. It was also preposterous that the mob would think one decent woman(knowing very little else about her) would be able to sway the whole jury. In real life, I think they would try to find a juror that was corrupt, and pay that person off.

In spite of all this, the movie held my attention until the end when I thought "How did Annie manage to get to remote Guatemala in time to raise a small army of assassins, get gun training herself, rehearse her son, and be in the precise place where The Teacher would show up?" also, if the Teacher had any sense, he would have flown, in order to get there before Annie. He acted surprised like such a thing hadn't occurred to him.

reply

[deleted]

She should have went to the police right away. It was stupid not to. It cost her her best friends life. She could have made sure her son was with her so they couldn't get to him. They were willing to help her but she just threw it away. Not very bright.

reply

[deleted]

The problem was that if she had gone to the police, she would have run into the same problem that she ran into the judge with. When she went to the judge's office and he won't hear her without involving the lawyers, the defendent, etc., one had to wonder -- as I am sure was going through Demi's mind -- how much was the judge in the back pocket of the mobsters as well?


Flanagan

reply

I just couldn't get past the basic premise ...
...that she appeared to be jumping for joy to be on the jury deliberating a Mafia -related murder, when the presiding judge was practically begging her to take a hall pass and get the hell out of Dodge.

reply