Esmeralda, the most overrated Disney heroine besides Belle/Ariel?

I disagree. Esmeralda was my favorite Disney heroine growing up (I was about eight when this movie came out). She's so much stronger than the other Disney female characters who just sit around hoping that, coincidentally, Prince Charming will just happen to walk by. Yes, Esmeralda dressed provocatively and was a dancer, but that was her job. She grew up surrounded by performers like that, and it was the only decent way she knew how to make money. Would you rather her go out and prostitute herself? And, in the Disney film, it's even suggested that she doesn't necessarily like dancing. When she sees all the things Quasimodo has made up in the bell tower, she says, "If I could do this, you wouldn't find me dancing in the streets for coins". Quasimodo then compliments her--"You're a wonderful dancer!"--she answers with, "Well, it keeps bread on the table, anyway". And just because she dressed a certain way didn't make her "slutty". Again, it was her job and part of the costume.

Esmeralda was a really warm-hearted person, and could fend for herself. When she prays in Notre Dame, she doesn't even ask for anything for herself; she prays for others. She was the only one who went up to comfort Quasimodo after the crowd turned on him during the Feast of Fools, and she was the only one who had the guts to stand up to Frollo, not just after the Feast, but when he had her tied to a stake, ready to be burned alive unless she slept with him, how did she answer? She spit in his face! Now that's ballsy! In short, I think she's a great character.

It sounds like you would definitely prefer how Esmeralda is in the book. Personally, I can't stand her in the book. In the book, she's rescued by Phoebus after Frollo tries to get Quasimodo to kidnap her for him. Instantly, Esmeralda is in love with the captain who saved her and Phoebus, who's been around the block many a time, senses this and knows she'll hang on his every word. And I don't want to say anything else without spoiling things if you haven't read the book, but, for the rest of the novel, Esmeralda (who's 16 in the book, by the way) spends all her time wailing about how much she loves Phoebus.

Nevermore!

I totally disagree. It's also impossible to be considered as an overrated heroine when she never gets any attention! It's not like she's in the Disney princess collection and they sell tons of dolls and toys with her image. If anything, I firmly believe she's underrated. She's been my favorite Disney character since the movie came out in 1996 and I've never felt she got the admiration she deserved.

Esmeralda was a street dancer in the original book. Disney was true to the plot. She is actually more covered than Ariel and Jasmine. Also, she's technically not of Gypsy decent. She was kidnapped as a baby and raised by gypsies so she can have 'white' features with tan skin for being out in the sun all day.

Esmeralda is strong and brave. She speaks out against the injustices to her people. That's huge. The risk she took to challenge Frollo in public should not be dismissed. That is admirable in itself. She can hold her own against the soldiers. She tough and smart. She knows how to make a quick and clever escape. She thinks for herself, speaks her mind, lives her own life. I think there are many feminist qualities to like about her. So what if she happens to be sexy? Being beautiful doesn't negate her other great attributes. She is just a performer and is never using seduction to manipulate people to get things she wants. If she was the kind of slut that used her sexuality to get her way then she would have given in to Frollo to stay alive. She values herself more than that. She maintains her integrity the entire film.

Ad Majorem Dei Gloriam Tua Luce Dirige

[deleted]

[deleted]

this post is a joke, right?

perhaps you should have changed your tagline. it has nothing to do with your context.

perhaps you should have changed your tagline. it has nothing to do with your context.

Bless this post.

I think her fanbase overrates her bad just because she's sexual and aggressive. Mulan is pretty overrated as a heroine but not as a character/princess, that is how she's sadly misunderstood.

Belle and Ariel will always be overrated, especially the former. "OMG like, Belle reads books! OMG like, Ariel's a mermaid!"

We're collecting dust, but our love's enough.